The Bourbon Thread!!

[ODLS1]

The Mariage is now discontinued in favor of a new(an recently released) Small Batch LE.

The 2009 Mariage has a 19 yo in it. Great stuff.

Yea I know, which is why I'm trying to find one :) . The new LE is good, but I hear the Mariage is better.

[McSmokey]

Are the BTACs out yet for this year?

[McSmokey]

Cleaning out my granddads house getting things in order to put it up on the market I come across a 375ml of O'Shaughnessy American Stock Kentucky Whiskey Tax Stamp 1977... Not that much flavor to it kind of like it has just lost its body over time... Now the two mason jars of 20 yr old homemade wine on the other hand are awesome. :tu

[TripleF]

Cleaning out my granddads house getting things in order to put it up on the market I come across a 375ml of O'Shaughnessy American Stock Kentucky Whiskey Tax Stamp 1977... Not that much flavor to it kind of like it has just lost its body over time... Now the two mason jars of 20 yr old homemade wine on the other hand are awesome. :tu


Very cool. Memories.....it's all how they're brought back. :tu

[Parshooter]

Are the BTACs out yet for this year?

Yes :noon

[ODLS1]

Are the BTACs out yet for this year?

Came and went in 2 days here. Probably not as bad elsewhere.

[BengalMan]

This weeks pick ups.

[dannysguitar]

Scored my 3rd bottle of Maker's 46 last night! :-)

[Matt-N-Ga]

The BTAC here in Ga have been slim, this is the only one I can find so far...still looking for Eagle Rare and both the Ryes.

[Matt-N-Ga]

This weeks pick ups.

I saw you talking about the special release Noe with ChiefHava, would love to here you thoughts on it when you get a chance to try it.

p.s. follow me on twitter so I can DM you...I think something happened the last time you tried (like my dumb ass clicked the deny button.)

[newcigarz]

Total Wine in Palm Beach Gardens still has last years Handy and Sazerac. Still no sign of this years Stagg.

[McSmokey]

Unless I've been scammed (and I'll know for sure when it gets here tomorrow) I am about to receive a bottle of Stagg.:noon:noon

[yourchoice]

This thread...I oughta...

I mentioned a week ago I am getting into bourbon again. I am also a scotch guy, and it has been my whiskey of choice for a while. A few months ago I was invited to a friends house for a poker game, and bourbon was the drink of choice. I'm very happy I went, because I found a love for bourbon again.

Over the course of the last week, I've read this thread (sheer awesomeness BTW) along with some other online info to help me make good choices for my purchases. Here's my current stash:
Woodford Reserve
Knob Creek
Eagle Rare (10)

Not listed is a recently polished off bottle of Bulleit. :)

The excitement for the release of the BTAC got the better of me, and I called my local liquor store to ask if they had any George T. Stagg. Luckily, they just got "a couple" bottles in today, and they're holding one for me. :banger He said $60, which sounds like a good price, but this is the first time I'm venturing into a limited bourbon, so IDK.

I'm headed there now to pick it up. Will probably pick up another bottle while there, either Evan Williams SB, or Van Winkle 12. If not, I may pick out something else. :)

I don't know if I should thank you guys or not??!?!! ;)

[JohnnyFlake]

This thread...I oughta...

I mentioned a week ago I am getting into bourbon again. I am also a scotch guy, and it has been my whiskey of choice for a while. A few months ago I was invited to a friends house for a poker game, and bourbon was the drink of choice. I'm very happy I went, because I found a love for bourbon again.

Over the course of the last week, I've read this thread (sheer awesomeness BTW) along with some other online info to help me make good choices for my purchases. Here's my current stash:
Woodford Reserve
Knob Creek
Eagle Rare (10)

Not listed is a recently polished off bottle of Bulleit. :)

The excitement for the release of the BTAC got the better of me, and I called my local liquor store to ask if they had any George T. Stagg. Luckily, they just got "a couple" bottles in today, and they're holding one for me. :banger He said $60, which sounds like a good price, but this is the first time I'm venturing into a limited bourbon, so IDK.

I'm headed there now to pick it up. Will probably pick up another bottle while there, either Evan Williams SB, or Van Winkle 12. If not, I may pick out something else. :)

I don't know if I should thank you guys or not??!?!! ;)

Before you go thanking us, we'd like you to have at least a dozen bottles of Bourbon, in your stash. That way we'll know your being sincere! LOL! :tu

[McSmokey]

Before you go thanking us, we'd like you to have at least a dozen bottles of Bourbon, in your stash. That way we'll know your being sincere! LOL! :tu


:tpd:

[weak_link]

I need some help with something and I know this is the correct place to ask.

I fully realize that Jim Beam is not even close to top shelf stuff but here goes. My father recently gave me two bottles of Jim Beam, unopened and in the boxes, from 1976. One is a special 'bicentennial edition' with a Norman Rockwell painting on the front (painting is called Pipe and Bowl), 4/5's size. The other is also 4/5's but is a 'collector's edition volume XI' featuring a James Lockhart image of a squirrel on the front.

So the big question- are these things worth anything? If they are not, I'll open one for my 40th next year. If they are, maybe I'll trade 'em for smokes or something. Any info you guys might be able to offer up would be greatly appreciated.

http://i353.photobucket.com/albums/r384/weak_link/DSCN0699.jpg?t=1289355593

[JohnnyFlake]

I need some help with something and I know this is the correct place to ask.

I fully realize that Jim Beam is not even close to top shelf stuff but here goes. My father recently gave me two bottles of Jim Beam, unopened and in the boxes, from 1976. One is a special 'bicentennial edition' with a Norman Rockwell painting on the front (painting is called Pipe and Bowl), 4/5's size. The other is also 4/5's but is a 'collector's edition volume XI' featuring a James Lockhart image of a squirrel on the front.

So the big question- are these things worth anything? If they are not, I'll open one for my 40th next year. If they are, maybe I'll trade 'em for smokes or something. Any info you guys might be able to offer up would be greatly appreciated.

http://i353.photobucket.com/albums/r384/weak_link/DSCN0699.jpg?t=1289355593

I have had at least half a dozen of those styles of Jim Beam bottles and I still have Volume XVI with some ducks on the bottle. Unfortunately, they have no real value as they never did become collectible. I've tried to sell them on eBay and some whiskey sites but I never did sell one. I eventually gave a few away and drank a few. Like you say Jim Beam is not a truly high end whiskey, but the blends in these bottles are very good and very smooth. I say break one open and give it a go. I don't think you be disappointed.

[ODLS1]

This thread...I oughta...

I mentioned a week ago I am getting into bourbon again. I am also a scotch guy, and it has been my whiskey of choice for a while. A few months ago I was invited to a friends house for a poker game, and bourbon was the drink of choice. I'm very happy I went, because I found a love for bourbon again.

Over the course of the last week, I've read this thread (sheer awesomeness BTW) along with some other online info to help me make good choices for my purchases. Here's my current stash:
Woodford Reserve
Knob Creek
Eagle Rare (10)

Not listed is a recently polished off bottle of Bulleit. :)

The excitement for the release of the BTAC got the better of me, and I called my local liquor store to ask if they had any George T. Stagg. Luckily, they just got "a couple" bottles in today, and they're holding one for me. :banger He said $60, which sounds like a good price, but this is the first time I'm venturing into a limited bourbon, so IDK.

I'm headed there now to pick it up. Will probably pick up another bottle while there, either Evan Williams SB, or Van Winkle 12. If not, I may pick out something else. :)

I don't know if I should thank you guys or not??!?!! ;)

Get it. If they have Van Winkle 12, get that too. What the hell, I swear the BTAC is more expensive here than any other place. $75 here. Granted good bourbon here is like gold. Van Winkle demand has skyrocketed the past year. People ask for it year 'round now. When we do get it, it's gone in a couple days.

[yourchoice]

Get it. If they have Van Winkle 12, get that too. What the hell, I swear the BTAC is more expensive here than any other place. $75 here. Granted good bourbon here is like gold. Van Winkle demand has skyrocketed the past year. People ask for it year 'round now. When we do get it, it's gone in a couple days.

They didn't have the Van Winkle 12, but I did pick up a bottle of Evan Williams Single Barrel along with the GTS.

While they didn't have the 12, they did have one bottle of the Pappy Van Winkle 23, and it was $169 (might have been $179, but I don't think so). I couldn't bring myself to buy it (as I don't feel I have the palate to appreciate it), but from what I've seen, that seemed like a good price.

I asked if they got any Eagle Rare 17, as I likely would have bought it, but they did not. I saw a bottle of Handy Sazerac behind the counter, but didn't jump to buy it as I don't know much about it (not that I know much about the GTS except for the rave reviews here and elsewhere :)).

[ODLS1]

They didn't have the Van Winkle 12, but I did pick up a bottle of Evan Williams Single Barrel along with the GTS.

While they didn't have the 12, they did have one bottle of the Pappy Van Winkle 23, and it was $169 (might have been $179, but I don't think so). I couldn't bring myself to buy it (as I don't feel I have the palate to appreciate it), but from what I've seen, that seemed like a good price.

I asked if they got any Eagle Rare 17, as I likely would have bought it, but they did not. I saw a bottle of Handy Sazerac behind the counter, but didn't jump to buy it as I don't know much about it (not that I know much about the GTS except for the rave reviews here and elsewhere :)).

Damn the 23yr is like $230+ here, and the 20yr is $130+. While Stagg is great, and the 12 and 15yr Van Winlkes (I haven't had the 20 or 23), the W.L.Weller of the BTAC is the best bourbon I have had to date. Straight/neat, 126 proof, yet still smooth packed with tons of flavor. I hear the Eagle Rare 17 is going downhill. Something about them storing it in stainless steel tanks so it doesn't age any longer since they won't have any more ready for awhile, so it's very limited. I've still never seen a bottle. The store managers snag it up immediately. Ugh. I don't have any experience with Ryes so the Handy and 18yr Sazerac didn't appeal to me. Hope you like the Stagg! I tried it neat, good but a little hot which took away from the flavor. Definitely needs a little water to tone it down a little to a lower proof. That Weller though is phenomenal neat. No burn, but a late warmth of the torso.

I am currently sipping on some Four Roses Limited Edition 2010 Barrel Strength. Very nice.

[McSmokey]

http://i857.photobucket.com/albums/ab138/McSmokey82/67a17418.jpg

[weak_link]

I have had at least half a dozen of those styles of Jim Beam bottles and I still have Volume XVI with some ducks on the bottle. Unfortunately, they have no real value as they never did become collectible. I've tried to sell them on eBay and some whiskey sites but I never did sell one. I eventually gave a few away and drank a few. Like you say Jim Beam is not a truly high end whiskey, but the blends in these bottles are very good and very smooth. I say break one open and give it a go. I don't think you be disappointed.

Thanks, sounds like I'll be having some aged cheap bourbon for my bday in April. :r :r I appreciate the info though. :)

[Matt-N-Ga]

Hell Yeah, guys, some awesome pick ups. I'm still not able to find anything but Weller here. If anyone runs into some Eagle Rare or Handy or Sazerac or Stagg, shoot me a PM, I'll be happy to buy some.

[McSmokey]

Hell Yeah, guys, some awesome pick ups. I'm still not able to find anything but Weller here. If anyone runs into some Eagle Rare or Handy or Sazerac or Stagg, shoot me a PM, I'll be happy to buy some.

I am still searching the web hoping to get lucky again, and I am going to the main ABC store here tonight to see if they happen to have any of the BTAC I was prepping to send you a link to the site I ordered my Stagg from but when I went back to get the link it was sold out. ;s

I have noticed several Olde World sites that actually have various BTACs from years gone by but you got to be ready to pony up the coin.

[bresdogsr]

Enjoying some Eagle Rare 10 tonight!

[McSmokey]

Just joined Straightbourbon.com anyone else a member over there? It looks like a wealth of information for newbs and vets alike.

[shark]

I tried a little Jefferson's Reserve and Elijah Craig 18 year old last weekend, and I was impressed. See, I'm more of a beer drinker and am uninitiated to bourbon, Scotch, etc. I picked up a bottle of Woodford Reserve today and tried a little bit and liked that as well. Oh no, here we go! Another thing to spend my money on!;)

[auburnfan1980]

I tried a little Jefferson's Reserve and Elijah Craig 18 year old last weekend, and I was impressed. See, I'm more of a beer drinker and am uninitiated to bourbon, Scotch, etc. I picked up a bottle of Woodford Reserve today and tried a little bit and liked that as well. Oh no, here we go! Another thing to spend my money on!;)

I'm with you on the JR....Knob Creek is definitely my go-to with Eagle Rare as the two I always keep at home. However, when I'm ready to splurge, I buy the $65 JR and savor it for very special smokes. If you're really in the mood to go all-out, try the Jefferson's Presidential Reserve. It's usually around $100/bottle, but it's probably the best bourbon I've ever tried.

[McSmokey]

Cracked open this years Stagg tonite at halftime of the Bama v. Miss St. game. Phenomenal!!

[yourchoice]

Cracked open this years Stagg tonite at halftime of the Bama v. Miss St. game. Phenomenal!!
I cracked mine open last night. It is very good, but man is it potent. It didn't help that I followed it with a pour of Knob Creek and a touch of Woodford Reserve! By itself, I really liked WR, but of the three last night, it was my least favorite. The higher ABV of the other two may have contributed to that. :)
Just joined Straightbourbon.com anyone else a member over there? It looks like a wealth of information for newbs and vets alike.

I checked it out and decided to join to. I have the same handle over there.

[McSmokey]

I cracked mine open last night. It is very good, but man is it potent. It didn't help that I followed it with a pour of Knob Creek and a touch of Woodford Reserve! By itself, I really liked WR, but of the three last night, it was my least favorite. The higher ABV of the other two may have contributed to that. :)

It is definitely potent I let my second pour breathe about 10 minutes and it opened up a lot.


I checked it out and decided to join to. I have the same handle over there.

It's actually sad I joined and my computer quits on me. For some reason my iPhone has an issue with the site so I am having to wait til I fix my desktop to get back on.

[McSmokey]

Picked up a bottle of Eagle Rare 10yr last night gonna have a pour of it after supper I think. Also going to to check out 2 more stores in town. One I used to be a regular at and the other I have never been to before so maybe I'll find something else new.

[Doctorossi]

It is very good, but man is it potent. It didn't help that I followed it with a pour of Knob Creek and a touch of Woodford Reserve! By itself, I really liked WR, but of the three last night, it was my least favorite. The higher ABV of the other two may have contributed to that.

Try them in a different order- you might be surprised by how differently they come across to you.

IMO, Woodford is the best of those three by a country mile, but that's another matter. :D

[McSmokey]

Had a pour of the Eagle Rare 10yr last night. The nose and the taste were both fairly sweet almost creamy but the finish had a strong oak taste and was kind of bitter.

[tx_tuff]

Oh man I love me some Eagle Rare 10 yr! But I think I found a new favorite a couple weeks ago, Russell Reserve 10 yr. That stuff was a flavor bomb for me, I love it! And it's about the same price as the Eagle Rare.

[auburnfan1980]

Had a pour of the Eagle Rare 10yr last night. The nose and the taste were both fairly sweet almost creamy but the finish had a strong oak taste and was kind of bitter.

Justin,

Just outta curiosity, what are you gonna pop open to drown your sorrows in next Friday?? :r

[McSmokey]

Justin,

Just outta curiosity, what are you gonna pop open to drown your sorrows in next Friday?? :r

"IF" it comes to that. Wild Turkey 101. Otherwise in honor of our victory I'll be trying something new. :D

[e-man67]

drinking a glass of Buffalo Trace as we speak accompanied with an 01 Party 898 NV...good.

[Barcode]

The wife just told me I have a bottle of Pappy's 20year old comming tomorrow.

[McSmokey]

The wife just told me I have a bottle of Pappy's 20year old comming tomorrow.

<== Jealous

As of yet Pappy is one of those I have been unable to find. Congrats to you sir :tu

[Barcode]

Thanks Justin, I have not yet tried the 20 year old I have tried the 12 and 15 tho and they were both GREAT. :banger

[McSmokey]

Picked up and had a pour of Russell Reserve 90 on Saturday think I'll have another one tonight

[JohnnyFlake]

I just found a bottle of Pappy 20 today but did not buy it. A new "Total Wine" opened up, not too far from me and the price is $115. That seems high to me but I am really not sure what the going price is for Pappy 20 now days.

[Bill86]

The wife just told me I have a bottle of Pappy's 20year old comming tomorrow.

NICE

I haven't had any of the Pappys. I REALLY REALLY want to try the 15 year. I hear it's the best of the Pappys.

[ODLS1]

I just found a bottle of Pappy 20 today but did not buy it. A new "Total Wine" opened up, not too far from me and the price is $115. That seems high to me but I am really not sure what the going price is for Pappy 20 now days.

That's pretty much how much it is here. It's weird how certain bottles of bourbon are cheaper outside of KY, like the BTAC.

NICE

I haven't had any of the Pappys. I REALLY REALLY want to try the 15 year. I hear it's the best of the Pappys.

I've only had the 15 and it is fantastic. Hard as hell to get here, and I work at a liquor store (managers snag them all up :su ). The Van Winkle 12yr is also fantastic, and the Old Rip Van Winkle 10yr 107 proof is awesome for the price, about $30.

I just picked up another 750 of the Weller 12yr. Great stuff for the price (about $22 here), but it only comes out a few times a year. I love all things Weller.

[Barcode]

I just found a bottle of Pappy 20 today but did not buy it. A new "Total Wine" opened up, not too far from me and the price is $115. That seems high to me but I am really not sure what the going price is for Pappy 20 now days.


I paid 102.00 for the bottle here in WA state.

[Ferrari5180]

Just picked me up a bottle of Elijah Craig 12. This will be my first time trying bourbon, I hope all goes well :) I usually drink scotch, so at least I got a head start.

[dannysguitar]

Buffalo Trace for me tonight fellas!

[Doctorossi]

Just picked me up a bottle of Elijah Craig 12. This will be my first time trying bourbon, I hope all goes well :) I usually drink scotch, so at least I got a head start.

That's a smack in the face for a first bourbon. Just be aware that it's about as unsubtle as they get.

[Ferrari5180]

That's a smack in the face for a first bourbon. Just be aware that it's about as unsubtle as they get.

Heard nothing but good things about this bottle. On another note, I'm used to drinking scotch, so not a total newbie here. I usually do a lot of research when it comes to buying drams. After all, it all comes down to personal individual preference and taste.

[tireiron]

In my opinion, craig 12 is one of the best values out there.

[Doctorossi]

Heard nothing but good things about this bottle.

Don't get me wrong- it's absolutely terrific stuff and an excellent value. I'm not knocking the product at all. I'm just trying to warn you that it's a bit 'deep end' for a first bourbon to try. Coming from the world of Scotch, it might frighten you away from some of the bourbons that might be a little more familiar/accessible to you.

[McSmokey]

Giving serious thought to buying the Buffalo Trace Exp. Being at work with nothing to do is bad for my wallet

[rizzle]

Picked up a bottle of this today. Any thoughts?

http://boozeblogger.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/BuffaloTrace_1.jpg

[rizzle]

Giving serious thought to buying the Buffalo Trace Exp. Being at work with nothing to do is bad for my wallet

Dude, I swear I didn't see your post before I posted mine. -(P

[McSmokey]

Dude, I swear I didn't see your post before I posted mine. -(P

:r I am actually going to buy a bottle of that on my way home, but the one I am talking about is an Experimental Series they did you can order it off of Party Source. :tu

[rizzle]

:r I am actually going to buy a bottle of that on my way home, but the one I am talking about is an Experimental Series they did you can order it off of Party Source. :tu

Gotcha. Any experience with this non-experimental one? ;)

[Ferrari5180]

:r I am actually going to buy a bottle of that on my way home, but the one I am talking about is an Experimental Series they did you can order it off of Party Source. :tu

The buffalo trace should be good. Consensus has it that this is a well priced and great tasting bourbon. I have never tasted it, nor is it available to me here in Montreal. However, if it were, I would have it without a doubt.

[McSmokey]

Not as of yet, but that will change tonight!

[Ken]

In my opinion, craig 12 is one of the best values out there.
It's been one of my favorites for some time, though 4 Roses Small Batch is in the same price range and is simply finger lickin' good. I really feel it has taken over being my favorite as a very damn good bourbon with an everyday price.

Right now I'm sipping on a Weller SR 7yr. A wheater!

[Ken]

Picked up a bottle of this today. Any thoughts?


BT is good bourbon. I actually wasn't too fond of my 1st bottle and the next one settled in very well. If you're not used to bourbon then the rye content might be a tad much.

[yourchoice]

Picked up a bottle of Rittenhouse Rye Bottled in Bond per many recommendations in this thread. I'm anxious to give it a try later tonight! (I am aware it is not a Bourbon. :tu)

[JohnnyFlake]

Picked up a bottle of Rittenhouse Rye Bottled in Bond per many recommendations in this thread. I'm anxious to give it a try later tonight! (I am aware it is not a Bourbon. :tu)

Who cares??? Close Enough :tu

[bresdogsr]

I like the BT. Can't get it in Jersey though so I sip sparingly.

[awsmith4]

Picked up a bottle of Rittenhouse Rye Bottled in Bond per many recommendations in this thread. I'm anxious to give it a try later tonight! (I am aware it is not a Bourbon. :tu)

I wish I could find more, Joey (ir13) found it at my local Total Wine then I picked up their last bottle months ago and they never restocked

[fricky]

An outstanding, inexpensive bourbon is Old Weller Antigue. It was a 7 year-old,107 proof, wheated bourbon. Recently, the age statement was removed when the Buffalo Trace Distillery redesigned the bottle and label. I tried the bourbon in the new bottle and I believe that it is even better. My fear was that Buffalo Trace may have started using younger bourbon and the taste would be inferior. The distillery stated that the bourbon is still 7 years old.

Another very good and inexpensive bourbon is Very Old Barton 100 proof. Unfortunately, it has very limited distribution.

[Bruins Fan]

I was in the liquor store last week and spyed a bottle of Jefferson and thought I would give it a try. Liked it very much was reasonably priced about 22.00.

[fricky]

A few years ago, there was a 15 year old Jefferson Reserve which was excellent. Subsequently, they started using younger bourbon and I thought that it was inferior.

The Jefferson's Presidential Select 17 yr old bourbon is excellent. I have had batches 1 and 2. They were great; however, they are expensive. Controversy continues concerning the source of the bourbon and if it is in fact Stitzel Weller bourbon. Personally, I don't care. I like it.

[Montano]

An outstanding, inexpensive bourbon is Old Weller Antigue. It was a 7 year-old,107 proof, wheated bourbon. Recently, the age statement was removed when the Buffalo Trace Distillery redesigned the bottle and label. I tried the bourbon in the new bottle and I believe that it is even better. My fear was that Buffalo Trace may have started using younger bourbon and the taste would be inferior. The distillery stated that the bourbon is still 7 years old.

Another very good and inexpensive bourbon is Very Old Barton 100 proof. Unfortunately, it has very limited distribution.

Thanks for the tip Doug ! I will be on the lookout for Old Weller.

[BengalMan]

I've done a lot of events with Jefferson's Reserve. Good people, and great bourbon. I have enjoyed all of their lines including Sam Houston, Jefferson's, Jefferson's Reserve, and the Presidential Select. The PS is awesome, but yes, expensive.

[TNT009]

Manhattan's Baby Bourbon is pretty good!

[rizzle]

BT is good bourbon. I actually wasn't too fond of my 1st bottle and the next one settled in very well. If you're not used to bourbon then the rye content might be a tad much.

I enjoyed it. A lot. Will definitley be buying more of that one. Cool to find new things by random and then really enjoy them.

[McSmokey]

I enjoyed it. A lot. Will definitley be buying more of that one. Cool to find new things by random and then really enjoy them.

Already picked up a second one. That so-called football game between the Tide and the Barn did the first one in. Good Stuff.

[rizzle]

Already picked up a second one. That so-called football game between the Tide and the Barn did the first one in. Good Stuff.

Same here.

[SvilleKid]

My latest purchase! Didn't realize the new Master's Collection was out. Maple Wood Finish! Has a bite to it, and an interesting, complex finish. Not as smooth as the Sweet Mash from last year, but much more complex. Found it at World of Beverages, on Camp Creek Pkwy, Atlanta.

[Bill86]

My latest purchase! Didn't realize the new Master's Collection was out. Maple Wood Finish! Has a bite to it, and an interesting, complex finish. Not as smooth as the Sweet Mash from last year, but much more complex. Found it at World of Beverages, on Camp Creek Pkwy, Atlanta.

Nice I've yet to bite on this years masters collection. How is it compared to say the 08 Masters? Which I found to be excellent. That bottle lasted me one glorious night.

[paris1129]

I am pretty jealous, Svillekid!! I am waiting to see if Santa brings me a bottle of that masters collection...

[newcigarz]

Picked up a bottle of this today. Any thoughts?

http://boozeblogger.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/BuffaloTrace_1.jpg



Good Stuff, this is my go to Bourbon.

[rizzle]

Good Stuff, this is my go to Bourbon.

I liked it a lot, Tony.

[paris1129]

Good Stuff, this is my go to Bourbon.

One of the best values out there in bourbon! Good choice!!

[Matt-N-Ga]

It's getting time to get some pics up guys. Lets get some Bourbon **** on here. I'll get my collection together tonight and get some pics posted with some short descriptions of each.

[bishjd123]

Pick this up today. It rates pretty good. We'll see.

http://i1220.photobucket.com/albums/dd455/bishjd123/IMG_1049.jpg

[CEC_Tech]

You can never good wrong with Woodford Reserve!

[dannysguitar]

I picked up a bottle of Eagle Rare. Any experiences with it?

[awsmith4]

It's getting time to get some pics up guys. Lets get some Bourbon **** on here. I'll get my collection together tonight and get some pics posted with some short descriptions of each.

:tt:tt

[Montano]

I picked up a bottle of Eagle Rare. Any experiences with it?

I enjoyed a bottle or 2 of Eagle ;)

[awsmith4]

I picked up a bottle of Eagle Rare. Any experiences with it?

Sorry Danny while chastising Matt I overlooked your question. I enjoy Eagle Rare a good deal. It is smooth and on the 'rye' side if there is such a thing. It is a great value for the price.

[dannysguitar]

Sorry Danny while chastising Matt I overlooked your question. I enjoy Eagle Rare a good deal. It is smooth and on the 'rye' side if there is such a thing. It is a great value for the price.

This is pretty much what I have read online. I'm a fan of Buffalo Trace, Wild Turkey and Maker's 46, so I think this should fit in nicely with my bourbons.

[Barcode]

So I had the HOLY GRAIL in my hand a bottle of Pappy Van Winkles 23 Year Old :dr, but could not pull the trigger due to the $250.00 price tag :td

[newcigarz]

I think this year that I am gonna pass on Stagg. I love the stuff, but just can't afford the price tag this time of year. It was tough going to the store and leaving it on the shelf. :(

[forgop]

Would Blanton's be a good start for a bourbon newb?

I just know that I literally haven't quite shaken the smell of anything resembling Jack Daniels from a bad episode when I was 15 years old to get the idea to try bourbon/whiskey/scotch ever again.

[BengalMan]

Blantons is good, don't know if I'd start with it though. I suggest Eagle Rare to start out with.

[dannysguitar]

Blantons is good, don't know if I'd start with it though. I suggest Eagle Rare to start out with.

I had some last night for the first time. Great bourbon!

[Matt-N-Ga]

Blantons is good, don't know if I'd start with it though. I suggest Eagle Rare to start out with.

Either that or some Basil Hayden. For me, it's a light, slightly spicy bourbon

[Bill86]

Would Blanton's be a good start for a bourbon newb?

I just know that I literally haven't quite shaken the smell of anything resembling Jack Daniels from a bad episode when I was 15 years old to get the idea to try bourbon/whiskey/scotch ever again.

:r Jack is sour mash whiskey and has a very unique smell. I don't think bourbon smells like it honestly. You should be fine. Regular Jack is not so good, but I do recommend Gentleman Jack. Tastes completely different, much more mellow and less harsh, not that nasty sour taste either.

All are great starting recommendations. I agree with all of them. I really did like the Eagle Rare 10 Year Single Barrel. Four Roses Single Barrel would be another great start. Both will run you roughly $35 a bottle. So not too pricey, and pretty common.

[forgop]

:r Jack is sour mash whiskey and has a very unique smell. I don't think bourbon smells like it honestly. You should be fine. Regular Jack is not so good, but I do recommend Gentleman Jack. Tastes completely different, much more mellow and less harsh, not that nasty sour taste either.

All are great starting recommendations. I agree with all of them. I really did like the Eagle Rare 10 Year Single Barrel. Four Roses Single Barrel would be another great start. Both will run you roughly $35 a bottle. So not too pricey, and pretty common.

I know bourbon, whiskey, and scotch are all a bit different, but they all smell close enough alike to me to bring back the memories (and lack thereof in same cases) that involved throwing up cool ranch doritos a lot. (And yes, I've never touched the cool ranch doritos ever since either. :r

[awsmith4]

I know bourbon, whiskey, and scotch are all a bit different, but they all smell close enough alike to me to bring back the memories (and lack thereof in same cases) that involved throwing up cool ranch doritos a lot. (And yes, I've never touched the cool ranch doritos ever since either. :r

I had a similar experience involving cheap whiskey and store brand Dr. Pepper about 10-11 years ago. Until recently I couldn't smell Dr. Pepper without feeling a bit sick.

[Bill86]

I know bourbon, whiskey, and scotch are all a bit different, but they all smell close enough alike to me to bring back the memories (and lack thereof in same cases) that involved throwing up cool ranch doritos a lot. (And yes, I've never touched the cool ranch doritos ever since either. :r

Yeah....I have had a few of those stories as well. Jager, goldschalger and any cinnamon liqueur, I cannot even smell them!

Oh man that's brutal even the close smells throw you for a spin, well there's always run and tequila. I guess all you can do is try. Good luck! :tu

[Parshooter]

Would Blanton's be a good start for a bourbon newb?
.

Blanton's would be a great start, albiet on the pricey side. Might put Bulliet on your to-try list. Half the price of Blanton's and easy to drink.

[Barcode]

:tpd:

[McSmokey]

OK Bourbon Drinkers of Tennessee, I am leaving Wednesday for my grandmothers house in Tullahoma. Anybody know a good store within say an hours drive of there?

[JohnnyFlake]

Would Blanton's be a good start for a bourbon newb?

I just know that I literally haven't quite shaken the smell of anything resembling Jack Daniels from a bad episode when I was 15 years old to get the idea to try bourbon/whiskey/scotch ever again.

Blantons may not be he best as a started, it is a very good bourbon but you need to have some experience with bourbons to appreciate Blantons.

To start out with, I suggest Old Fitzgearld, Old Forester, Old Grandad or probably the best choice may be Wild Turkey 101.

[e-man67]

I like Eagle Rare a lot...with that I also drink Buffalo Trace, Old Weller, Woodford, Rittenhouse Rye, WT Rye..I am sure there are others but drinking makes you forget.

[SvilleKid]

I don't think there are any rules as to starter bourbons. I don't think price is a rule when it comes to tastes, personally. There are expensive bourbons out there that I like, but also that I don't like. Same with cheaper bourbons.

Personally, I didn't care for Bullit. Gave the bottle away after two drinks. But, that's me and my tastes. Bourbon will be like cigars. Each will have his own taste, and will drink what he likes. I started liking bourbon with Marker's Mark. Thought it was the best, until I tried Woodford Reserve. Thought it was the best, til I tried Blanton's. Thought it was the best until I tried.... Well, you get the picture! I have had bottles of over two dozen bourbons at a time in the past. Still have over a dozen. I probably enjoy sippin' Conecuh Ridge more than most of them, but it's because, personally, I like molasses, and I get strong hints of molasses from that one, more than any other. But again, it's a personal taste thing!

One thing to note: ALL bourbons go downhill after they are opened. They oxidize. The longer they are open, the more they will lose quality. Thus, you are better served to have only a few bottles opened at a time, drink those up before you open new bottles. I try to finish any open bottles within a year or less. I'm not a nightly drinker, sometimes not even a monthly drinker. Thus, I seldom have more than a couple of bottles open at a time.

The best bet for those new to bourbon is to buy smaller size bottles to get an idea of the specific bourbons. Then, graduate to larger bottles for the ones you like the most. This will be a problem for many of the upper end bourbons, as they usually are bottled in 750 ml only (at least for my state). Good bars, with a good selection of top-shelve bourbons, is a good way to try them one glass at a time. While it may cost you $5- $10 or more for a glass, it's better than $75 or more for a bottle that you then find isn't to your liking.

I would suggest starting with the bourbons "neat". I'm not a fan of diluting bourbon with water. Some people use ice, which gives a "spectrum" of tastes, from almost neat at the start, to maybe half and half at the end as the ice melts. Personally, after I've had a sip or two neat, less bourbon and more water pales, and I lose interest. But, I usually take a good hour to enjoy a couple ounces of bourbon, because I truly sip slowly, and fully enjoy each sip. If I wanted to do shooters, I sure wouldn't recommend anything above $20 a bottle!

Again, all the above is MY preferences. And, just like cigars, those are going to be different with each person. For those looking for answers on the "starter" question, by all means, look at the suggestions here. However, DO NOT be discouraged because you don't find one or more of the suggestions to your liking. And, like cigars, remember, if at first the specific bourbon doesn't bring cheers of joy to your taste buds, don't dismiss it forever. Develop your palette, learn what you like, then go back and give the discarded ones another try. You might like it the second time around.

[rizzle]

Santa dropped me a nice bottle of Blanton's in my stocking Christmas morning. That Santa is a pretty good wife. :tu

[e-man67]

Santa dropped me a nice bottle of Blanton's in my stocking Christmas morning. That Santa is a pretty good wife. :tu

That's funny..I got one too!

[tx_tuff]

Last two bottles I bought where Russel's Reserve (love it) and Makers 46, then was given a bottle of Woodford Reserve for my birthday (still unopened). So I have 3 bottles of bourbon, prob the most I have had at one time LOL. I really don't drink to much so they should last me awhile.

What sucks is every time I see this thread I want to go buy another bottle ha ha.

[Ken]

Santa dropped me a nice bottle of Blanton's in my stocking Christmas morning. That Santa is a pretty good wife. :tu
Nice! A very good pour.

The wife pays attention to me apparently, she handed me a bottle of VWFR 12yr. She said she didn't love me enough for the 23yr. :-(

I was hoping for a gift set of Wild Turkey, I like their glasses that come in the set. I guess I'm going a hunting for some myself.

[akakirby]

I was just wondering if any knows if Pappy Van Winkle sells any of there Bourbon in the little airplane sized bottles, I would love to try some but cannot afford to buy a whole bottle, any of you all ever seen them?

I also got a set of Whisky stones for Christmas I cannot wait to try out!

http://www.teroforma.com/Set_of_9_Whisky_Stones_20187.html

[McSmokey]

Mrs. Claus left a bottle of George T Stagg in the stocking and a bottle of bakers under the tree.

[fricky]

None of the van Winkle whiskies are bottled in minis. If you want an opportunity to sample various bourbons, you should consider attending the Bourbon Sampler in Bardstown, Kentucky. It is one of the Kentucky Bourbon Festival events and will be held the last Saturday in April 2011. All of the major distilleries are there handing out samples of their bourbons. For more information, go to The Kentucky Bourbon Festival website.

[Ken]

You have some good taste! I just picked up this bottle of Willett's! It’s extremely well balanced and smooth.


My wife picked up the liter for me for my birthday and this is one fine bourbon. I had to run out and grab some cheaper favorites to keep me off that bottle. Definitely good juice.

[Ken]

, I would love to try some but cannot afford to buy a whole bottle, any of you all ever seen them?

Your best bet unfortunately might be a good bourbon/whiskey bar. I cracked open mine last night for the game and it's just freakin' wonderful.

And the best thing about bourbon is you can find something tasty and respectful in your price range.

[akakirby]

Thanks guys, I did a lot of searching on the internet and could not find any mini's, oh well, guess I will have to save up for a bottle. I am really enjoying the Makers 46 currently. Think I will pick up Buffalo Trace next as i have heard good things and the price is right!

[BengalMan]

Had a nice haul this week. Bottle of Van Winkle 12, 15, and the 107 proof. I can't get enough of the 12.

My favorite right now, unfortunately is the rare bottle of Fred Noe Bookers that I picked up. Such an amazing, and complex bourbon. Too bad I'll likely never come across another...

[JohnnyFlake]

Had a nice haul this week. Bottle of Van Winkle 12, 15, and the 107 proof. I can't get enough of the 12.

My favorite right now, unfortunately is the rare bottle of Fred Noe Bookers that I picked up. Such an amazing, and complex bourbon. Too bad I'll likely never come across another...

Can you post a picture of the Fred Noe Bookers?

I'd love to see what it looks like.

[warren G.]

the last two bottle, I had to scoop it up :P
http://i122.photobucket.com/albums/o256/blueDick/STA_6132.jpg

[akakirby]

anyone have source for the van winkle 12 year or maybe the 15 year? I have some limited viaje releases to trade?

[awsmith4]

the last two bottle, I had to scoop it up :P
http://i122.photobucket.com/albums/o256/blueDick/STA_6132.jpg

:jd:jd

Nice score!

[JohnnyFlake]

anyone have source for the van winkle 12 year or maybe the 15 year? I have some limited viaje releases to trade?

What is this, I am not familiar with that name?

[warren G.]

:jd:jd



my exact reaction... it was the last two bottle.

The SA open the glass case, and I only wanted one. I sat there for a good 2 minute thinking. Then he just hand me the last bottle and I was like why not?!

[akakirby]

What is this, I am not familiar with that name?

Its a cigar brand.

[e-man67]

Got some Blantons for Christmas..it's ok..not super impressed. Fav is still Eagle Rare.

[ODLS1]

Having a Weller 12yr pour right now. Weller is so underrated. 12yr, 90prf (wish it was 100), very nice bourbon, for $22 a 750 where I got it. Can't beat it.

The best bourbon I've had to date, definitely over Pappy 15 - William Larue Weller 12yr, barrel proof unfiltered, 126 proof. Amazing. Neat, room temp, no burn and crazy smooth, amazing flavor, then a late warming of the torso. Never had a bourbon like it.

[McSmokey]

having a pour of Bakers 7yr 107 proof. Warming up for the celebration to come, I think I will get the Stagg out tonite though I'll be the only one drinking nobody else that will be around can handle it. What's everybody else drinking tonite?

[warren G.]

I crack open up my Eagle Rare 17 last night...smell and taste so gooood :)

[McSmokey]

Ordered a bottle of William LaRue Weller and Sazerac 18yr today :xxx :xxx

[fricky]

I was fortunate enough to obtain a few bottles of 15 yr old Elmer T Lee special release, single barrel bourbon. The regular bottling is quite good. I expect this special release to be exceptional.

[potlimit]

Got a sweet gift of Woodford Masters Reserve from somebody as a belated (sep 12th!) birthday present last week lol. Anyone had this, any good?

[JohnnyFlake]

What are your 1st, 2nd & 3rd, best "New To You" Bourbons that you tried in 2010?

If you do not have 3, don't sweat it. Just one, or even two, will be fine.

Don't hesitate to elaborate if you'd like!

[McSmokey]

#1 George T Stagg 143 proof
#2 Bakers 107 proof
#3 Eagle Rare SB 90 proof

[Ken]

Had a nice haul this week. Bottle of Van Winkle 12, 15, and the 107 proof. I can't get enough of the 12.

Showoff! :D I made a run to Party Source the other day just for some VW12. I picked up others as well, but those were just collateral damage. I just needed another one of those bottles to hang onto for a bit.


Having a Weller 12yr pour right now. Weller is so underrated.

I haven't had the 12yr, though based on their other bottles and prices I can only image it is more than worth the cost. Great bourbons for a generous price tag.

[Steve]

My wife gave me a bottle of Wodford for Christmas...I approve!

http://oldchurchbbq.com/sharedpictures/2010-12-25_Christmas/2010-12-25_Christmas%20002.jpg

[Powers]

Nice catch Steve! Class doesn't start still Wednesday so I picked up a handle of Ezra Brooks 90 proof today in case i get bored :D

[Steve]

That sounds like a good way to get ready for class Michael!

[McSmokey]

Nice catch Steve! Class doesn't start still Wednesday so I picked up a handle of Ezra Brooks 90 proof today in case i get bored :D

That will definitely help pass the time. :D

[McSmokey]

2010 WLW and ER17 being shipped to my door tomorrow so hopefully I'll have it by the end of next week.

[76GTFan]

I was just wondering if any knows if Pappy Van Winkle sells any of there Bourbon in the little airplane sized bottles, I would love to try some but cannot afford to buy a whole bottle, any of you all ever seen them?

I also got a set of Whisky stones for Christmas I cannot wait to try out!

http://www.teroforma.com/Set_of_9_Whisky_Stones_20187.html


That is friggin sweet!

You have inspired me to order some. Dint think I will buy the 30 dollar glasses however.

[76GTFan]

Can I get some opinions?

What do you guys prefer, Buffalo Trace or Willetts?
Haven't had the Willetts, but don't want to fork the cash 1st tasting.

[McSmokey]

Never had Willetts but BT is good neat or mixed.

[JohnnyFlake]

Never had Willetts but BT is good neat or mixed.

:tpd: BT is quite decent, never had Willetts.

[shark]

...must stop reading this thread! Don't need any more ODO!!!!!!:D

[Matt-N-Ga]

Can I get some opinions?

What do you guys prefer, Buffalo Trace or Willetts?
Haven't had the Willetts, but don't want to fork the cash 1st tasting.

This question entirely depends on your personal tastes. To me, Willetts carries a more Rye flavor that up until recently, I was not a fan of.

The Buffalo Trace, hands down my favorite everyday bourbon. But like I said about the Wlletts, thats for me.

If you can only get one, Id say get the BT first. Then next time get the Willetts. Chances are you'll like them both.

[RevSmoke]

Buffalo Trace is excellent, but I haven't had the Willetts, so I cannot speak to the comparison.

[RevSmoke]

Got some Eagle Rare over Christmas. I like it!

[fricky]

Can I get some opinions?

What do you guys prefer, Buffalo Trace or Willetts?
Haven't had the Willetts, but don't want to fork the cash 1st tasting.

This question is not easy to answer. Kentucky Bourbon Distillers does not yet have an operating still. They will have one ready to start in the near future. They have been buying whiskey from other distillers and aging it in their warehouses. The source of the whiskey is not made public.

They sell barrels and bottle the contents under the Willett label. They include proof, barrel number, bottle number, and the name of the purchaser on a separate label. I have bottles of 4, 6, 7, 12, 17, and 18 year old bourbons that were barrel proof and not chill filtered. I have Willett Rye that is 22 years old, barrel proof, and not chill filtered. The best bourbon with the Willett's label that I ever had was a 12 year sold by The Party Source in Bellvue, KY a few years ago. The Party Source has a few special Willett releases.

The Rye that I have is from barrels purchased by a few friends. The Rye is outstanding.

Compared to their special barrel-proof, non-chill filtered bourbons the bourbon in the pot-still bottle is mediocre.

[J.W.]

Enjoying a pour of Blantons this evening. SMOOOOOOTH. Thinking about a little Wild Turkey for a nightcap.

J.W.

[McSmokey]

Why am I one of four people in this god forsaken building when the university is closed? All I had to say was "The roads are impassable between me and the highway" and would be at home with some Baker's to warm my insides, but no I am here working away getting that double time and a half.

[Steve]

Dedicated man there Justin :D

[rizzle]

Why am I one of four people in this god forsaken building when the university is closed? All I had to say was "The roads are impassable between me and the highway" and would be at home with some Baker's to warm my insides, but no I am here working away getting that double time and a half.

Snow in T-town?

[McSmokey]

Snow in T-town?

We only got a dusting of snow but it is sittin on top of about a 1/2 inch of ice from the freezing rain. Roads are little slushy but for the most part drivable

[J.W.]

Got 6.5 in N. MS. Tupelo area

J.W.

[McSmokey]

On my way home to eat wings pick out a bourbon and Watch the SEC Roll on!!! Hard to choose but I have narrowed it to Baker's, Woodfords Maple Finish, or buying something new.

[Matt-N-Ga]

On my way home to eat wings pick out a bourbon and Watch the SEC Roll on!!! Hard to choose but I have narrowed it to Baker's, Woodfords Maple Finish, or buying something new.

Best part of those choices is you can't go wrong :banger

[Powers]

On my way home to eat wings pick out a bourbon and Watch the SEC Roll on!!! Hard to choose but I have narrowed it to Baker's, Woodfords Maple Finish, or buying something new.

Ezra Brooks and I will be doin' the same thing tonight my friend :tu

[McSmokey]

Me and Baker had an excellent evening watching a damn tight championship game.... War Eagle..... damn that hurt.

[bajaraider]

We were sipping on some wonderful Woodford Reserve last night for the game. And of course a few smokes as well.

[Steve]

Very nice

[Ken]

My wife gave me a bottle of Wodford for Christmas...I approve!


I like those glasses that came in the Woodford giftset. I picked up a couple different sets myself just because I wanted the glasses; didn't get the Woodford though.

What do you guys prefer, Buffalo Trace or Willetts?
Haven't had the Willetts, but don't want to fork the cash 1st tasting.

The Willett I've had has been flat out good stuff. :dr
But if price is a concern then under $25 you'll be in good company with;

BT, 4 Roses SB, EC12, Weller SR.

[Steve]

They are nice


I like those glasses that came in the Woodford giftset. I picked up a couple different sets myself just because I wanted the glasses; didn't get the Woodford though.

[SvilleKid]

The Willett I've had has been flat out good stuff. :dr


Been wondering about the Willett. Nice bottle. My sister's store in Tennessee has it in, and I have been thinking about getting her to hold me a bottle. Think I'll tell her to go ahead.

[76GTFan]

Well here goes. Couldn't resist trying.

http://emob1129.photobucket.com/albums/m507/Rubarb1990/0120ce6e.jpg?t=1294959841

[McSmokey]

My Bottles of 2010 WLW and ER17 arrived safe and sound yesterday there shall be a tasting tonite now that they have acclimated to my room temp.

[Perfecto Lounge]

I attended Whiskey Fest in San Francisco last October...great event (even though it was taken over by Shanken). Had the chance to sample lots of Scotch, Bourbon, Whiskey and Whisky.

Highlights were the Glen Rothes line and the opportunity to sample some of the best of the Pappy line.

However, the biggest highlight was meeting Master Distiller Lincoln Henderson of Woodford fame. He is the genius behind the new Angel's Envy...truly some tasty stuff! :dr Here's a quick write-up
http://www.bourbonblog.com/blog/2010/06/08/angels-envy-bourbon/

Can't wait to get my hands on some

[JohnnyFlake]

Has anyone tasted the Angel's Envy Bourbon yet?

If so, what are your thoughts?

Is it pricey?

[McSmokey]

Never heard of it but it sounds interesting probably not available here :(

[warren G.]

Find a new shop and wow they had a great selection.
I was curious and ask if they had any Pappy van winkle 15 or 20. Guy went into the back and got me the 20....
http://i122.photobucket.com/albums/o256/blueDick/IMG_6281.jpg

[Ferrari5180]

I am drinking Elijah Craig 12 and it is mighty fine :)

[McSmokey]

Find a new shop and wow they had a great selection.
I was curious and ask if they had any Pappy van winkle 15 or 20. Guy went into the back and got me the 20....
http://i122.photobucket.com/albums/o256/blueDick/IMG_6281.jpg

Jealous. Pappy isn't offered anywhere near me as far as I've found. Hoping to score a bottle when I go to Atlanta in February.

Tonight I picked a bottle of Rebel Reserve going to let it sit until tomorrow night any thought on this one?

[warren G.]

Awesome good luck man.

I am drinking Elijah Craig 12 and it is mighty fine :)

Indeed, I always enjoy a glass of EC12 :)

[Michael629]

Hello all,
New to the forum and it looks as if the most important things in life are here,beer,spirits,and cigars.
Bengalman, I grew up in Cincinnati, miss it.
Here in North Carolina you can make 200 gallons of "spirits" a year. I was wondering if there are any makers here that can give me some information on distilling.
Thanks
Michael

[warren G.]

bought a bottle not so long ago and I finish it pretty quick. I had to pick up another one...
http://i122.photobucket.com/albums/o256/blueDick/IMG_0337.jpg

[Barcode]

bought a bottle not so long ago and I finish it pretty quick. I had to pick up another one...
http://i122.photobucket.com/albums/o256/blueDick/IMG_0337.jpg

I have been wanting to try that just have not been able to find it in WA.

[Parshooter]

Opened a bottle of Michter's Straight Rye the other night. I would be happy to have to drink this all the time, great stuff :D

[yourchoice]

Had a pour of Knob Creek last night while smoking an '08 Mag 46. Went together very nicely. :)

I need to make a run to the store...my bourbon and scotch selection has mysteriously shrunk! ;)

[Tredegar]

Made my first bourbon purchase yesterday Elijah Craig 18 year old Single Barrel along with a Partagas Series P No. 2. Great bourbon, great smoke.

[Matt-N-Ga]

Made my first bourbon purchase yesterday Elijah Craig 18 year old Single Barrel along with a Partagas Series P No. 2. Great bourbon, great smoke.

Try the EC 12 yr. Most I have talked with like the 12 better than the 18 and its cheaper...win-win. Either way, you have a great pairing there bro, enjoy. :banger

[paris1129]

Try the EC 12 yr. Most I have talked with like the 12 better than the 18 and its cheaper...win-win. Either way, you have a great pairing there bro, enjoy. :banger

Really? I actually prefer EC 18 by a wide margin. Either way, they are both good.

[warren G.]

I have been wanting to try that just have not been able to find it in WA.

really great bourbon, and it was around $40 bucks down here.

[Frodo]

Made my first bourbon purchase yesterday Elijah Craig 18 year old Single Barrel along with a Partagas Series P No. 2. Great bourbon, great smoke.

Try the EC 12 yr. Most I have talked with like the 12 better than the 18 and its cheaper...win-win. Either way, you have a great pairing there bro, enjoy. :banger

Really? I actually prefer EC 18 by a wide margin. Either way, they are both good.

I've had both bottles and they are very different. The 18 is right on the edge - as oaky as a bourbon can get without going too far. The 12 is much more...rounded. Some decent complexity on the 12 and more balance.

[76GTFan]

Buffalo Trace just started producing half gallons to my knowledge. That or they are new to GA. :banger

[HK3-]

Picked these up last night. Bang for the buck, Prichards Double Barreled is pretty darn good. My only negative is that the finish is a bit tart.

http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/ll115/Lvmesum3zs/Picture3038.jpg

[Matt-N-Ga]

Buffalo Trace just started producing half gallons to my knowledge. That or they are new to GA. :banger

They half gallons are new to Georgia. BT and the distributor just recently inked a deal that gives Georgia complete coverage of all the BT production line, including the White Dog Mash 1, which is amazing. If you see it, buy it. It's in 375 ml bottles and is fresh from the still, has an amazing nose and a corn sweetness that is one of a kind.

[GreekGodX]

Picked these up last night. Bang for the buck, Prichards Double Barreled is pretty darn good. My only negative is that the finish is a bit tart.

http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/ll115/Lvmesum3zs/Picture3038.jpg

:dr I concour on the Prichards

One day I will buy some Pappy's, one day :D

On a side note had a pour of Elijah Craig 12 yo at a bar the other night, and it was 8 bucks!? I realized when I got the bill I should have forked over the few extra bucks for the 18 yo. Definitely worth it IMO

[HK3-]

:dr I concour on the Prichards

One day I will buy some Pappy's, one day :D

On a side note had a pour of Elijah Craig 12 yo at a bar the other night, and it was 8 bucks!? I realized when I got the bill I should have forked over the few extra bucks for the 18 yo. Definitely worth it IMO

I will have to track down and try some of this Elijah Craig.

[BigCat]

I will have to track down and try some of this Elijah Craig.

I really like the 12 too. Can't beat $20 for a fifth. I've never had the 18, however.

[HK3-]

I really like the 12 too. Can't beat $20 for a fifth. I've never had the 18, however.

Well, for that price I will pick up one of each to compare. :)

[E.J.]

Well, I went to pick up some beer for the weekend....but ended up with these.... 50% bourbon is better than no bourbon for a pic in the bourbon thread....

http://img508.imageshack.us/img508/5462/drinkox.jpg (http://img508.imageshack.us/i/drinkox.jpg/)

[76GTFan]

They half gallons are new to Georgia. BT and the distributor just recently inked a deal that gives Georgia complete coverage of all the BT production line, including the White Dog Mash 1, which is amazing. If you see it, buy it. It's in 375 ml bottles and is fresh from the still, has an amazing nose and a corn sweetness that is one of a kind.

Thanks! Yeah I talked to my local shop and he invited me to a private tasting provided by the distributor soon. I am speechless!!

[Matt-N-Ga]

What shop do you go to ? I frequent Minks in Marietta, and he also gave me a tasting of it, that's what made me buy it, it's amazing.

[Barcode]

OK here is the question, does anyone know what type of cigar is being smoked on the Pappy Van Winkles Label?

[HK3-]

OK here is the question, does anyone know what type of cigar is being smoked on the Pappy Van Winkles Label?

Just from looking at it... no way to tell. Maybe with a phone call or some googling an answer can possibly be found.

[warren G.]

gotta stop visiting my favorite store, just bought a bottle 2010 WLW
http://i122.photobucket.com/albums/o256/blueDick/IMG_0348.jpg

[Lucky_Hippo]

Just started easing into the bourbons pool a few weeks ago. I see a fast and slippery slope ahead and I have to thank who ever it was that suggested the ice cubes with the Woodford Reserve (Maybe Bangelman?). I tasted a glass neat and although nice, wasn't hitting my taste profiles and I couldn't grab the maple/sweetness I've read from others. Second glass was over two cubes of ice and man what a colorful difference. The complete spectrum changed to lip smackingly tasty.

Some very good suggestions in these pages. I've started a list of bottles to grab and you will all be recieving your portion of the bill to help compensate for my new found hobby very soon.

:tu :noon

[SvilleKid]

Just started easing into the bourbons pool a few weeks ago. I see a fast and slippery slope ahead and I have to thank who ever it was that suggested the ice cubes with the Woodford Reserve (Maybe Bangelman?). I tasted a glass neat and although nice, wasn't hitting my taste profiles and I couldn't grab the maple/sweetness I've read from others. Second glass was over two cubes of ice and man what a colorful difference. The complete spectrum changed to lip smackingly tasty.

Some very good suggestions in these pages. I've started a list of bottles to grab and you will all be recieving your portion of the bill to help compensate for my new found hobby very soon.

:tu :noon

Just a word to those that might be new to bourbons. Once you open a sealed bottle of bourbon, it starts a slow process of oxidation. This speeds up the less there is in the bottle (more room for air). The bourbon won't "go bad", in the sense that wine can turn to vinegar, it will lose flavors over time. Once it's down to 1/3 or less, may be time to have some friends over, and enjoy the remainder! So, try to finish up one bottle before opening another, or don't have too many different bottles open at one time.

Just food for thought for anyone new to this slope!!

[Lucky_Hippo]

Just a word to those that might be new to bourbons. Once you open a sealed bottle of bourbon, it starts a slow process of oxidation. This speeds up the less there is in the bottle (more room for air). The bourbon won't "go bad", in the sense that wine can turn to vinegar, it will lose flavors over time. Once it's down to 1/3 or less, may be time to have some friends over, and enjoy the remainder! So, try to finish up one bottle before opening another, or don't have too many different bottles open at one time.

Just food for thought for anyone new to this slope!!

Thanks for the heads up. At this time, I've been buying small bottles that I can finish in a week or two until I figure out what direction my taste are going to take me.:tu

[HK3-]

Over the weekend at the VCM herf we sampled both the 20 and 23 year Pappy back to back to compare the difference. It was pretty significant. Some mentioned that they make a 25 year pappy. Anyone ever had the chance to sample that one yet? I'm on a mission to find a bottle now. :)

[Aero95]

Great thread! My wife just surprised me with a weekend trip to the bourbon trail in April. I have chosen Four Roses, Buffalo Trace, Woodford, and if we have time Wild Turkey. All I have to do now is find a good restaurant in the Lexington area.

[yourchoice]

FINALLY Buffalo Trace is available in NJ. Picked a bottle up today after work for $23.99 +tax. I'll finally be able to try this often discussed bourbon. :tu

What's strange is they have distributed their antique collection here for a long while. Why NJ didn't/couldn't get BT, I have no idea.

[warren G.]

FINALLY Buffalo Trace is available in NJ. Picked a bottle up today after work for $23.99 +tax. I'll finally be able to try this often discussed bourbon. :tu

What's strange is they have distributed their antique collection here for a long while. Why NJ didn't/couldn't get BT, I have no idea.

That is pretty strange. I love BT, pretty versatile. Nice enough to sip and it's pretty good in an Old-Fashioned :)

[ODLS1]

Eh, BT is alright, overpriced IMO. You can get better for the price.

[yourchoice]

Eh, BT is alright, overpriced IMO. You can get better for the price.

What do you prefer over it at that price point? I tried it the other night and thought it was good, but not great. At the price point, I like EWSB better, and Eagle Rare is very good too, but a touch more $.

[ODLS1]

Weller Antique 107 comes to mind. If BT is about $23, the WA107 should be about $20. If you run across Weller 12 yr, get it. It's only $22 around here when it comes out.

[BigCat]

What do you prefer over it at that price point? I tried it the other night and thought it was good, but not great. At the price point, I like EWSB better, and Eagle Rare is very good too, but a touch more $.

I'd rather have Elijah Craig 12 at a slightly lower price. I think it has more flavor and body. I agree BT is good, but not great. EC is better to my palate.

[yourchoice]

Weller Antique 107 comes to mind. If BT is about $23, the WA107 should be about $20. If you run across Weller 12 yr, get it. It's only $22 around here when it comes out.

I actually did pick up a bottle of Weller 107 a month or more ago. I agree it is pretty good for the price, I forgot that one! I'll keep my eye open for the 12 yr.

I'm reserving my judgement on BT until I have it a few more times. Once isn't enough, but I wasn't overly impressed the first time.

[yourchoice]

I'd rather have Elijah Craig 12 at a slightly lower price. I think it has more flavor and body. I agree BT is good, but not great. EC is better to my palate.

Haven't tried EC yet...I'll have to put it on my short list. Thanks! :tu

[ODLS1]

I also agree with the EC12.

[RevSmoke]

Last bottle of Buffalo Trace I got was $19.95. What is better at that price point?

I also got a bottle of Eagle Rare, but that was $20.95, another very nice one.

Have not found the Elijah Craig locally.

[Matt-N-Ga]

Last bottle of Buffalo Trace I got was $19.95. What is better at that price point?

I also got a bottle of Eagle Rare, but that was $20.95, another very nice one.

Have not found the Elijah Craig locally.

A close price point is the Evan Williams Single Barrel. Amazing stuff, and only 23.95 around GA, similarly elsewhere I'm sure.

[Fishbeadtwo]

been hitting the Rebel yell lately.....

[smokin5]

Has anyone tried the Costco Kirkland Bourbon yet?
Just read about it today. 7 years old, 103 proof,
about $20/liter. Rumor has it it's Jim Beam made.

[chippewastud79]

Just started on some Elijah Craig. Bought some for bbq sauce the other week and cracked it for some drinks tonight. Very nice, especially for $20 :tu

[Patrick B]

Has anyone tried the Costco Kirkland Bourbon yet?
Just read about it today. 7 years old, 103 proof,
about $20/liter. Rumor has it it's Jim Beam made.

a twitter buddy said it was ok....

[BengalMan]

Just picked up a bottle of extremely limited first run Angel's Envy which is made by famed distiller Lincoln Henderson. Going to crack it open and have a little later this week, will let you know how it is. Info can be found here:
http://www.bbqandbourbon.com/2011/03/29/kentuckians-get-first-chance-to-experience-angels-envy-super-premium-bourbon/

[replicant_argent]

Has anyone tried the Costco Kirkland Bourbon yet?
Just read about it today. 7 years old, 103 proof,
about $20/liter. Rumor has it it's Jim Beam made.

Bought it. Had a sip or 2 neat. Good flavors, a little hot, I need to try it with a splash to see how it opens up, and then maybe with a cube before passing judgment overall. A little raisin-y aroma, and oak and vanilla to me, with a sniff as I look at the bottle for you.
So far, I think it will be well worth the 20 bucks.

It is distilled and bottled by "The Clear Spring Distilling Co. Clermont frankfort KY."

[Wanger]

Bought it. Had a sip or 2 neat. Good flavors, a little hot, I need to try it with a splash to see how it opens up, and then maybe with a cube before passing judgment overall. A little raisin-y aroma, and oak and vanilla to me, with a sniff as I look at the bottle for you.
So far, I think it will be well worth the 20 bucks.

It is distilled and bottled by "The Clear Spring Distilling Co. Clermont frankfort KY."

Just did a quick search...that's the Jim Beam Distillery, apparently.

[replicant_argent]

It is also where the aliens landed.

[Aero95]

Just got a few bottles of A.H. Hirsch 16 and trying to decide if I want to open a bottle up or not right now.

[Wanger]

It is also where the aliens landed.

:tf:tf:tf

[shemp]

bought the kirkland borboun, and for $20.00 it is very nice. Over a cube is the best i think, but even neet it is decent. It is much better than many other equivelant low end burbouns out there. I would put it on a playing field with buffalo trace or makers.

[Frodo]

Just got a few bottles of A.H. Hirsch 16 and trying to decide if I want to open a bottle up or not right now.

WOW! A peice of American distilling history no doubt. Wish I could get some for a reasonable price although I think those days are gone...

[macsauce13]

All I have to do now is find a good restaurant in the Lexington area.


Check out:

Malones
Sal's

[smokin5]

bought the kirkland borboun, and for $20.00 it is very nice. Over a cube is the best i think, but even neet it is decent. It is much better than many other equivelant low end burbouns out there. I would put it on a playing field with buffalo trace or makers.

I've been curious about picking up some of this.
But since my Costco's selling Makers Mark ("Mother's Milk")
for $29/1.75 Liter, I haven't seen a reason yet.

[Ken]

Been wondering about the Willett. Nice bottle. My sister's store in Tennessee has it in, and I have been thinking about getting her to hold me a bottle. Think I'll tell her to go ahead.
Well here goes. Couldn't resist trying.


What say you two? It comes in a nice looking package but the juice stands up to the image on my taste buds.

Last bottle of Buffalo Trace I got was $19.95. What is better at that price point?

Have you had Weller Special Reserve or 4 Roses Small Batch? Both are pretty darn good especially at their price; WSR $13-16 & 4RSB $22ish. I've been drinking more of the Weller SR because it's good and the price is just hard to pass up for what you get.

[SvilleKid]

What say you two? It comes in a nice looking package but the juice stands up to the image on my taste buds.


Have you had Weller Special Reserve or 4 Roses Small Batch? Both are pretty darn good especially at their price; WSR $13-16 & 4RSB $22ish. I've been drinking more of the Weller SR because it's good and the price is just hard to pass up for what you get.

Ken

I haven't opened the bottle yet. I've got four different bottles of bourbon open already. I need to finish at least two of them off before I open any new bottles.

I've had Weller's (had a glass a week ago), as well as 4 roses. Don't currently have any in my collection. Nothing against either of these, I just don't currently have the room!!

[Bill86]

I was wondering about the Weller Special Reserve, it seemed too cheap. $17 at my local means probably 14-15 in the city. I didn't buy it. I might have to try it though. I love the William Larue Weller 67.4% :dr 134.8 proof :dr

[Barcode]

Just picked up a bottle of Knob Creek Single Barrel will have to try it this weekend. :dr

[Frodo]

I was wondering about the Weller Special Reserve, it seemed too cheap. $17 at my local means probably 14-15 in the city. I didn't buy it. I might have to try it though. I love the William Larue Weller 67.4% :dr 134.8 proof :dr

If this is the 107 proof bottling, I loved it a while back. Unbelievable value for the coin. Wish we could still get it up here...

[BengalMan]

The Weller 107 is a fantastic bourbon. There are many amazing value bourbons out there, don't let price fool you.

Barcode, the Knob Creek Single Barrel is a nice upgrade from the standard Knob for sure.

[Ken]

I haven't opened the bottle yet. I've got four different bottles of bourbon open already. I need to finish at least two of them off before I open any new bottles.

Ha, doesn't look like a bad problemat all. The only issue I had with my Willett was that it was a 1.75l and it just didn't last as long as I'd hoped. Hope you enjoy yours.



I was wondering about the Weller Special Reserve, it seemed too cheap.

There are many amazing value bourbons out there, don't let price fool you.

Yep, you can't always judge a bourbon by the sticker. The WSR is good stuff. I even prefer it over the Antique 107. I enjoy the taste of the 4 Roses SB compared to the Single Barrell, which sames me money. There's a lot of value to being a bourbon drinker.

[Aero95]

Check out:

Malones
Sal's

Thanks :tu

[76GTFan]

What is the hype with the White Dog Mash? Grabbed a bottle of it and it tasted like I thought it would. Unbarreled bourbon whiskey. I think more of a novelty than a tasty product. I love Buffalo Trace, but now I understand why this was originally only sold in the gift shop.

[awsmith4]

What is the hype with the White Dog Mash? Grabbed a bottle of it and it tasted like I thought it would. Unbarreled bourbon whiskey. I think more of a novelty than a tasty product. I love Buffalo Trace, but now I understand why this was originally only sold in the gift shop.

I think it is just a novelty, but to me it is a tasty novelty. Its interesting to be able to taste the product so you know how much barrel aging really affects the whiskey.

[Trent0341]

Great thread! My wife just surprised me with a weekend trip to the bourbon trail in April. I have chosen Four Roses, Buffalo Trace, Woodford, and if we have time Wild Turkey. All I have to do now is find a good restaurant in the Lexington area.

Like Macsauce said both Malones or Sals are good. If you hit Malones I highly recommend the bone in filet. If you're looking for something other than a steak Bellinis is nice on Main St. Enjoy your trip (assuming its not already over)

[macsauce13]

Like Macsauce said both Malones or Sals are good. If you hit Malones I highly recommend the bone in filet. If you're looking for something other than a steak Bellinis is nice on Main St. Enjoy your trip (assuming its not already over)

Also Murray's! and again for a lunch or 'snack' Alf-Alfa's downtown is really good!

[ODLS1]

Finally picked up some Bulleit bourbon. Pretty nice. I was hoping for a little more to it. Fairly mellow, but the flavors that are there are pretty nice. Maybe I've just been drinking too much Weller 12yr recently.

[mosesbotbol]

bought the kirkland borboun, and for $20.00 it is very nice. Over a cube is the best i think, but even neet it is decent. It is much better than many other equivelant low end burbouns out there. I would put it on a playing field with buffalo trace or makers.

Good to hear. I saw it for the first time last weekend. I have to finish off the Blantons before I buy another bottle of Bourbon.

[SvilleKid]

Finally picked up some Bulleit bourbon. Pretty nice. I was hoping for a little more to it. Fairly mellow, but the flavors that are there are pretty nice. Maybe I've just been drinking too much Weller 12yr recently.

I guess I've just missed something with the Bullitt! Had a bottle gifted me 4-5 years ago, and I found it to be almost too harsh to drink. I gave it away, with only 2 drinks poured out of it. Haven't had the desire to re-try. Maybe I'd better look for a small bottle, and see if I am missing something, or if Bullitt just doesn't agree with my tastebuds!!!

[ODLS1]

I guess I've just missed something with the Bullitt! Had a bottle gifted me 4-5 years ago, and I found it to be almost too harsh to drink. I gave it away, with only 2 drinks poured out of it. Haven't had the desire to re-try. Maybe I'd better look for a small bottle, and see if I am missing something, or if Bullitt just doesn't agree with my tastebuds!!!

I heard it was fairly spicy, but I didn't really get that. The more intense flavor is the more I like it, with anything.

[Bruins Fan]

I also found bullitt to be harsh,shared it with my buds while out ice fishing,heck they drink anything :r

[Bill86]

Yep, you can't always judge a bourbon by the sticker. The WSR is good stuff. I even prefer it over the Antique 107. I enjoy the taste of the 4 Roses SB compared to the Single Barrell, which sames me money. There's a lot of value to being a bourbon drinker.

I agree I like the small batch four roses better than the single barrel. Although given the choice I'd gladly close my eyes and drink either.

I'll pick up a bottle of WSR and see what I think. Maybe tomorrow.

I generally avoid cheap booze because I hate the hangovers. Although frankly even Jim Beam goes down plenty fine with me and that's like $35 for 1.75 liters. However, cheap tequila....:pu

Good tequila :tu

[ODLS1]

Yea WSR > Jim Beam for sure. They are usually the same price. I've been wanting to try the small batch FR forever. Single Barrel is excellent IMO.

[Bill86]

Don't hesitate, the small batch is very good especially for the price. ~$28 or so last I remember. I've definitely killed a few bottles, and I'll say they didn't last more than 2 ...MAYBE 3 days. Very tasty.

[ODLS1]

I just don't have the money to buy bottles anymore. I really had to convince myself to buy that Bulleit, haha. I drink way more beer (homebrew :) ), just have small pours of bourbon here and there. It's definitely on the list though. It's around $23 here.

[Bill86]

Oh wow nice, someday I'll get into homebrewing......someday.

[fricky]

Is anybody going to The Bourbon Sampler in Bardstown Kentucky? The sampler is one of The Boubon Festival events. All of the major distillers are present and handing out samples of their bourbon in glasses with their logo. You may keep the glasses. In addition, local restaurants and caterers have tables with various food items. It is a great opportunity to taste various bourbons and meet master distillers. The cost is $40 and well worth it.

[Ken]

Maybe I've just been drinking too much Weller 12yr recently.
I just don't see the problem. :D

I guess I've just missed something with the Bullitt!
Me personally, I bought a bottle, drank it, and walk past it now. This applies to the new Early Times release as well.

[Bill86]

Alright I have to admit I was going to pick up a bottle of WSR but this bottle of High West Rendezvous Rye caught my eye. So I scored that instead.

[ODLS1]

I just picked up (I have got to stop convincing myself to buy stuff, hah) Bulleit Rye 95 for my first Rye. Not bad. I don't have anything to compare it to, but I was expecting it to be a little different.

[Parshooter]

I just picked up (I have got to stop convincing myself to buy stuff, hah) Bulleit Rye 95 for my first Rye. Not bad. I don't have anything to compare it to, but I was expecting it to be a little different.

I tried some of this last night. Definitly was missing something. It didn't have the sweet, spicy that I've had in some ryes. I think I'll stick to the regular Bulleit.