Review: Argenti Exile

[markem]

It is hard to say what the numbers mean because you don't define a scale. I think, from your text, that the range for each category may be different.

Sounds like you like it (I was gifted 2 handfuls of these this past week) and that you recommend it. The scale is what is confusing to me.

[OHRD]

Originally Posted by markem

It is hard to say what the numbers mean because you don't define a scale. I think, from your text, that the range for each category may be different.

Sounds like you like it (I was gifted 2 handfuls of these this past week) and that you recommend it. The scale is what is confusing to me.

This is a definite recommend! Here is our scoring system:

10 Point Scoring System

* Pre-light – considers pre-light draw and aroma, quality of wrapper, head, and foot, difficulty and quality of roll, and overall exterior quality including label and packaging. (2 points)

Burn – considers quality and hold of ash, draw, thickness of smoke, and issues with touch-up and re-lighting. (2 points)


Flavor/taste – considers flavor profile, general interest in continuing the current smoke and future purchasing, and complexity or consistency. (3 points)


Overall – considers value of the smoke, smoking experience and enjoyment, and other minor points of interest not covered in other scoring categories. (3 points)

Scoring Breakdown

* 10-9.5: Superior Toastability (Enough Said Toast)
* 9.4-9.0: Excellent Toastability (Get Me a Match, Quick, Toast)
* 8.9-8.5: Good Toastability (Everyday Toast)
* 8.4-8.0: Average Toastability (Humpday Toast)
* 7.9-7.0: Below Average Toastability (Yard Toast)
* 6.9-below: Zero Tostability (Not Worth the Match You Struck Toast)