Te Amo is a love/hate cigar, Puros Indios is the only other brand I can think of that has such polarized opinions.
My feeling on (both); a cigar I would not care to smoke often but which I really enjoy every once in a while. A very distinct blend easily recognized. This is a cigar you really should sample one or a 5er before buying a box unless you get a great deal.
While Te-Amo is often in my humi; I would not call it a "go-to" cigar; some of the suggestions in this thread should be considered.
Another thought:
Te Amo (and Puros Indios): sort of a White Castle/Crystal slider in the cigar world to me.