Casa Magna BTT at Detroit Herf

Originally Posted by auburnfan1980

This cigar tasted like a bit of green tea mixed with dirt. Yeah...a whole lot of dirt. Sorry to play the role of Debbie Downer, but I was not at all impressed with this stick. I defended Aficionado's Top 25 last year amongst much criticism, but IMHO the selection of this stick as #1, much less in the top sticks of 2008 altogether causes them to lose a little credibility in my eyes.

Jason

You should try another Jason.... sounds like you had a bad one.... I don't believe it deserves #1 though don't believe it's a crap stick either.