....and the Cigar Afficianado #1 for 2012 is...

[RobR1205]

CA's top 25 has always made me ask myself lots of questions, one being:

I wonder how the cigars are chosen for tasting, considering there are hundreds, if not thousands, of varieties out there to choose from....Do a bunch of cigar lovers sit in a room for a year and review cigars? (because if so, I'm putting in a job app!)