Very Old Montecristo cigars and Box

well, not being an expert, the cigar lit, didnt burn up like a dry stick, tasted pretty good ( didn't leave some bitter or moldy old taste in my mouth, smelled good, had a good draw, burned a good 4inches of ash before falling off, and I had to re-light it once when it got about 2 inches from the end and i had it sitting in ashtry a few minutes. Does any of this make it a good cigar? who the hell knows lol but I would smoke them again!