[mikeyj23]

If store policy says you can't return gift cards, then it is what it is. It's certainly not illegal for them to enforce that policy. Even if they did return it, they'd probably only give you store credit, which would come in the form of...a gift card. Seems to me like it's just one of those mistakes where you punch yourself afterward, but deal with it and move on. Use the giftcards gradually over the next five years - anytime you need toothpaste, use the giftcard at Wal-Mart. Need a gallon of milk, use the giftcard. They'll probably go faster than you think.