What Punch had the best flavor profile for you?

[Outlaw God]

I haven't had a Punch cigar for years and can't remember the profile, what one out of these major offering is your favorite?
And the size that was best also?
Thanks! :tu

Punch
Punch Bareknuckle
Punch Deluxe
Punch Gran Cru
Punch Gran Puro
Punch Rare Corojo
Punch Rare Corojo 10th Anniversary
Punch Uppercut

[dave]

IMVHO,
Punch - boring as heck
Punch Bareknuckle - awful
Punch Deluxe - nh
Punch Gran Cru - had, but so memorable I remember nothing about it
Punch Gran Puro - did nothing for me
Punch Rare Corojo - only NC Punch I ever wanted more than once - esp in the little perfecto
Punch Rare Corojo 10th Anniversary - nh
Punch Uppercut -worse than the Bareknuckle

[AdamJoshua]

I personally enjoy the Punch Punch. :2

[Outlaw God]

IMVHO,
Punch - boring as heck
Punch Bareknuckle - awful
Punch Deluxe - nh
Punch Gran Cru - had, but so memorable I remember nothing about it
Punch Gran Puro - did nothing for me
Punch Rare Corojo - only NC Punch I ever wanted more than once - esp in the little perfecto
Punch Rare Corojo 10th Anniversary - nh
Punch Uppercut -worse than the Bareknuckle

Wow fast response, that's a concise observation, maybe why I never picked one up again.:D
Thanks brother :tu

[Simple1]

I personally enjoy the Punch Punch. :2

This. Best one ever. ;)

[Buckeye Jack]

Black Prince myself....Ninfas arent bad either!

[kelmac07]

Punch is one line that I've had zero luck with.

[Porch Dweller]

Punch Punch, although it's been years since I had one
Rare Corojo
Bareknuckle, although it needs some rest

[RepoGenetic]

Punch is one line that I've had zero luck with.

I would agree with this. Taken quite a few shots at it too, as occasionally I would think I was overlooking them, or that they couldn't all be that meh. But trying another one would always end the same.

Einstein's definition of insanity - doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results. So yeah, I don't try Punch anymore. :D

[Outlaw God]

I would agree with this. Taken quite a few shots at it too, as occasionally I would think I was overlooking them, or that they couldn't all be that meh. But trying another one would always end the same.

Einstein's definition of insanity - doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results. So yeah, I don't try Punch anymore. :D

Must be why I haven't tried one for years :rolleyes:
Thanks

[hammondc]

I've always liked the Punch Rare Corojo in the rothschild size. Even though they are not rare and do not contain any Corojo.

[shilala]

I remember enjoying the Gran Puro and Rare Corojo both.

[Col. Kurtz]

Superfino. Best. RE. Ever.

[icehog3]

Ninfas arent bad either!

No, they are not. :dr

Superfino. Best. RE. Ever.

I agree, wish they had made more.

Adding:

Punch Descobridores RE
Punch Petite Punch

and

Punch Necatres for the win

[Robulous78]

When I was a noob I remember the Punch Gran Cru to be an o.k. maduro.

Notice. OK.

The Rare Corojo and 1oth Anni Corojo are quite nice and pretty easy to get your hands on.

[smokin5]

NC speaking, I enjoy the Gran Puro.
One of the few cigars that really pairs well with tequila.

Rare Crojo is pretty nice, too.

[dvickery]

ss#1

derrek

[longknocker]

Only One I Like Is The Gran Puro. Great Cigar, IMO.:2:tu

[CoffeeWaterBeer]

I see Punch getting a lot of "meh" reviews, with the word "boring" coming up quite often. I used to grab standard Punch Robustos I suppose because they were familiar, easy to find, and weren't bad. I'm curious to have another go at them now that I feel like I may have a (somewhat) more discerning palette.

That's the great thing about this hobby. There's never a shortage of new things to try, and the deeper you go, revisiting old smokes can be a new experience.

[rennD]

Ninfas. Aged Punch is also one of my faves.

[Sadden]

Punch London Club

Great Flavored Short sticks.
One Dimensional so some of you guys might get bored.

[Gabe215]

You couldn't pay me to smoke a NC Punch

[icehog3]

You couldn't pay me to smoke a NC Punch

Not even for.....



http://i196.photobucket.com/albums/aa73/icehog3/AEvil_zps86dd8443.png (http://s196.photobucket.com/user/icehog3/media/AEvil_zps86dd8443.png.html)




ONE MILLION DOLLARS???


:D

[Outlaw God]

Not even for.....



http://i196.photobucket.com/albums/aa73/icehog3/AEvil_zps86dd8443.png (http://s196.photobucket.com/user/icehog3/media/AEvil_zps86dd8443.png.html)




ONE MILLION DOLLARS???


:D
:lr :lr :lr

[688sonarmen]

Donkey- Totally did it for me.

[Buckeye Jack]

I can remember back 10-15 years ago buying the NC punch rothschild maduro maduro's...they were pretty popular back then. Do people still like those?

[Col. Kurtz]

Donkey- Totally did it for me.

:r:r:r:r:r