Review: Ashton VSG Eclipse Tubo

[elderboy02]

Date: 1/27/11

Cigar: Ashton VSG Eclipse Tubo (6 x 52)

Cost: I don't remember

Drink: Coke (The best cola)

Appearance: This cigar comes in a metal tube. The wrapper is a bit rough. I am giving the appearance a 5/10.

Pre-Light: I get a bit of cocoa on the pre-light draw.

Construction: The draw was pretty loose. When I cut the head, the wrapper cracked around the head which is strange because I store my cigars at 65% RH and I never have this problem



Taste of the cigar: I tasted a little bit of chocolate and it also tasted a little bit nutty. The flavor seemed to be lacking. I smoked about 1.5" and then I put it out.



Strength: This is a medium bodied cigar.

Summary: I have never cared for Ashton VSG's. I have tried so hard to like them because a lot of people like them. These in my opinion are not worth the cost. There are so many better smokes out there that cost a lot less. I am never going to buy this cigar again. I give this cigar a 2/10.

[kelmac07]

I feel the same way about the VSGs Dan...I try like hell to like 'em. But I can't.

[Zeuceone]

I had the same issue with the head. I actually cut up the wrapper from another cigar up so I could "patch" it. That gave me a better draw but want perfect.

[hscmit]

more for me

I havent tried this particular size, but am sorry you didnt enjoy it

[x man]

I smoked it at 1st release, i liked it but it was a bit underfilled.
11.00 msrp, i think.

I'm sorry you didn't enjoy it. With the VSGs, I happen to think the Spellbound size is miles ahead of the rest of them for some reason. I did try the Eclipse once and did enjoy it, however. Different strokes for different folks, if you don't like them you don't have to force it. We all have different tastes. I for one am not a fan of the Padron 64s natural (maduros are a bit better), most people would label me crazy, but it's my preference.
btw. what would rather smoke for the price? I'll give it a try.

[sobranie10]

VSG are a excellent cigar they can be a little bit harsh and strong if fresh, but longer you let them sit for a month or years they marry flavors and smooth out to a nutty, express coffee with a bit of citrus flavor very yummy.

[hscmit]

and I like them fresh

different strokes for different folks

[sobranie10]

Fresh or Aged brothers and sisters they are very well made and very consistent.

[CRIMPS]

The one I have, I enjoyed. This seems like a polarizing smoke...

[elderboy02]

Originally Posted by KingJaffeJoffer

...what would rather smoke for the price? I'll give it a try.

In what price range? Tatuaje Petit Cazadore, My Father, El Triunfador No. 1, VR Famoso, Bolivar Corona Extra, Dirty Rat, etc.

For about what you paid for the VSG. Thanks! I'll give some of those a try.

[elderboy02]

Originally Posted by KingJaffeJoffer

For about what you paid for the VSG. Thanks! I'll give some of those a try.

No problem man Also, check out a Don Pepin Garcia Serie JJ Maduro and a Don Pepin Garcia Cuban Classic.

[Krish the Fish]

I've never had a VSG myself... Never really saw the appeal when I could have an Anejo for the same price(ish).

This is putting it farther back on my "to try" list.

[Bruzee]

That is too bad you didn't like the VSG. It is one of my all time favorites. I have to agree that the spellbound is probably the best size. Thanks for the review.

[x man]

Originally Posted by sobranie10

Fresh or Aged brothers and sisters they are very well made and very consistent.

Man i havnt seen a Balkan can since 1974

[Bill86]

Sorry to hear, I've yet to try a VSG but this makes me never want to look for one. I had a VERY similar experience with a Diamond Crown Maximus Robusto No. 5 today. Good size stick, smelled good, but flavorless and muted.

[longknocker]

Sorry To Hear Your Disappointment, Dan. How Long Had This One Rested? Do You Think A Year Or So Of Rest Would Help?

Hate to hear the experience didn't go well. I smoked my first VSG a few years ago and thought it was awful, ended up giving a ton away as I wasn't going to be smoking them. But, my tastes have changed (a number of times) and can't even keep any in the humi I enjoy them so much now.

[elderboy02]

Originally Posted by longknocker

Sorry To Hear Your Disappointment, Dan. How Long Had This One Rested? Do You Think A Year Or So Of Rest Would Help?

I picked this one up at the B&M last month. I have also smoked some aged ones, but I didn't care for those either. Besides, you age Cubans, I don't see why us as consumers should have to age NC's It seems Ashton should age them another year or so on their end if a lot of people like them with some age.