Opinion on these Handguns

BeerAdvocate · 04-17-2011, 09:07 PM

I am in the market for a new Handgun. What do you think of one of these 3:

Springfield XD
Smith and Wesson M&P 9mm
Glock 17

loki · 04-17-2011, 09:13 PM

depends on what you want to do with it but all of them are fine guns

MiamiE · 04-17-2011, 09:14 PM

Those are some big boys. I live the S&W MP, but I would almost always go with the Glock. I hate the Springfield safety mechanism!

loki · 04-17-2011, 09:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MiamiE

Those are some big boys. I live the S&W MP, but I would almost always go with the Glock. I hate the Springfield safety mechanism!

so you're anti-grip and trigger safety? can i ask why

emopunker2004 · 04-17-2011, 09:26 PM

Glock all day

Remo · 04-17-2011, 09:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by emopunker2004

Glock all day

I used to say that until about 6 mos. ago when I was one of the test guinea pigs for the S&W M&P for our department, now with all things equal I love the M&P. I loved my glock because it went bang every time, clean, dirty, wet, dry it didn't matter the thing always worked.

Well I have put a few thousand rounds through my M&P and it functions every bit as good as the Glock, the big upside of the M&P is that it is just a sexy gun, the lines are alot better than the Glock and the interchangeable back strap is great (although the Glock Gen 4 has them now). The big thing is the angle of the grip, I was always fighting to find the front sight of my Glock but not with the M&P I pull up and my front sight is right in line with the rear no more canting the front sight down to get a good sight picture, the grip on the M&P is more like a 1911. anyways my .02

Negncic · 04-17-2011, 09:43 PM

I carry the M&P .40cal subcompact. Feels great. Shoots great. Great gun.

JE3146 · 04-17-2011, 09:50 PM

Depends on your shooting stance. Test fire each (or at least hold and aim) before coming to a conclusion. It won't be much benefit to you to hear it from a bunch of people with different opinions. You've already settled on 3 great platforms.

Glock will obviously be the benchmark to beat, but neither the XD or the M&P are slouches.

As someone noted, the grip safety on the XD is a huge annoyance. One that would prevent me from owning it. Trigger safeties aren't that big of a deal imho.

Ranger_B · 04-17-2011, 11:35 PM

Say what you will about grip safeties but they do come in handy now and then. I.E. http://acidcow.com/pics/18523-worn-l...ccidental.html

I would say all three are comparable. Best shoot them and see which shoots and feels best to you. Dont forget to consider all the other things like holsters, spare mags and and sight changes you would want when looking into price.

Barcode · 04-17-2011, 11:57 PM

I have 2 XD's one 45 and one 40 and love them both. Have never had a problem with either one.

Bill86 · 04-18-2011, 12:10 AM

I personally hate the glock frame more than life itself. They were not meant to be held by the human hand.

The best thing to do though is either shoot each of them or at least go to a gun shop and decided which fits your hands best.

Bunker · 04-18-2011, 02:33 AM

I am not a fan or any of the pin fired guns, I want to see a hammer and appreciate the old school mechanics involved.

But, if I had to chose one of your three it would be Glock (but I would go with the 19).

MiamiE · 04-18-2011, 04:53 AM

I grew up firing Glocks. It's what I know and love. Havent shot myself yet! I would go with a compact model as well. Glock 19. The G17 is a beast. Go with the G19 (9mm) or the G23 (.40).

04-18-2011, 05:02 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bill86

I personally hate the glock frame more than life itself. They were not meant to be held by the human hand.

I agree...Personally, not a very comfortable grip. The S & W has three interchangeable grips you can choose from, if I'm not mistaken. I bought the S&W M&P .40 and I love it.

Eleven · 04-18-2011, 06:06 AM

This poll is invalid without the "All of the above" choice

captain53 · 04-18-2011, 06:20 AM

Depends on which one fits your hand and operates in a way that feels comfortable to you. Even though I am not an M&P fan they are all good quality but the one that fits me may not fit you so my preference does not matter.

emopunker2004 · 04-18-2011, 06:29 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Remo_5_0

I used to say that until about 6 mos. ago when I was one of the test guinea pigs for the S&W M&P for our department, now with all things equal I love the M&P. I loved my glock because it went bang every time, clean, dirty, wet, dry it didn't matter the thing always worked.

Well I have put a few thousand rounds through my M&P and it functions every bit as good as the Glock, the big upside of the M&P is that it is just a sexy gun, the lines are alot better than the Glock and the interchangeable back strap is great (although the Glock Gen 4 has them now). The big thing is the angle of the grip, I was always fighting to find the front sight of my Glock but not with the M&P I pull up and my front sight is right in line with the rear no more canting the front sight down to get a good sight picture, the grip on the M&P is more like a 1911. anyways my .02

Had an m&p, prefer the glock

emopunker2004 · 04-18-2011, 06:31 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Angus

I agree...Personally, not a very comfortable grip. The S & W has three interchangeable grips you can choose from, if I'm not mistaken. I bought the S&W M&P .40 and I love it.

Gen 4 glocks have the interchangeable grips

elderboy02 · 04-18-2011, 06:57 AM

I love my Glock's. I will say though, that I have a S&W M&P 9mm and it is phenomenal. Just as good as my Glock.

Rent both at a local range and see which one suits you better

HollywoodQue · 04-18-2011, 07:15 AM

I was issued the Glock almost 12 years ago and then, I thought this was one of the better semi-auto's out there.....BUT, we Detroit Police Dept, changed over to the S&W MP40 and I love it. I have shot expert with the Glock since I was issued it back in 1997, usually scoring no less than 237 out of 250.

Since changing to the M&P, my highest score was 249 out of 250. I love the interchangable hand grips and my groups are more consistence.

I vote for the S&W MP all day. Just my

View Poll Results: Pick a Handgun
Springfield XD	8	14.04%
Smith and Wesson M&P 9mm	9	15.79%
Glock 17	26	45.61%
Other	14	24.56%
Voters: 57. You may not vote on this poll

04-17-2011, 09:07 PM	#1
BeerAdvocate BeerHunter Join Date: Mar 2009 First Name: Travis Location: Topeka, KS Posts: 1,912 Trading: (45)	Opinion on these Handguns I am in the market for a new Handgun. What do you think of one of these 3: Springfield XD Smith and Wesson M&P 9mm Glock 17 __________________ *I Brew the Beer I Drink*

04-17-2011, 09:13 PM	#2
loki H.A.T.E Join Date: Oct 2008 Location: Pittsburgh pa Posts: 1,484 Trading: (7)	Re: Opinion on these Handguns depends on what you want to do with it but all of them are fine guns

04-17-2011, 09:14 PM	#3
MiamiE I'm nuts for the place Join Date: Feb 2009 First Name: Erick Location: Miami, FL Posts: 2,892 Trading: (38)	Re: Opinion on these Handguns Those are some big boys. I live the S&W MP, but I would almost always go with the Glock. I hate the Springfield safety mechanism!

04-17-2011, 09:26 PM	#5
emopunker2004 Central Fla rollin Join Date: Jan 2011 First Name: Justin Location: Winter Springs, FL Posts: 6,171 Trading: (46)	Re: Opinion on these Handguns Glock all day __________________ Cigar Asylum: Where all are equal, unless you are from CA, then you are more equal.

04-17-2011, 09:43 PM	#7
Negncic Killed By Death Join Date: Oct 2008 First Name: Jim Location: West Islip NY Posts: 499 Trading: (74)	Re: Opinion on these Handguns I carry the M&P .40cal subcompact. Feels great. Shoots great. Great gun.

04-17-2011, 09:50 PM	#8
JE3146 Jordan #2 Join Date: Oct 2008 First Name: Jordan Location: Tigard, OR Posts: 2,115 Trading: (26)	Re: Opinion on these Handguns Depends on your shooting stance. Test fire each (or at least hold and aim) before coming to a conclusion. It won't be much benefit to you to hear it from a bunch of people with different opinions. You've already settled on 3 great platforms. Glock will obviously be the benchmark to beat, but neither the XD or the M&P are slouches. As someone noted, the grip safety on the XD is a huge annoyance. One that would prevent me from owning it. Trigger safeties aren't that big of a deal imho.

04-17-2011, 11:35 PM	#9
Ranger_B Have My Own Room Join Date: Apr 2009 First Name: Frank Location: North Carolina Posts: 1,321 Trading: (31)	Re: Opinion on these Handguns Say what you will about grip safeties but they do come in handy now and then. I.E. http://acidcow.com/pics/18523-worn-l...ccidental.html I would say all three are comparable. Best shoot them and see which shoots and feels best to you. Dont forget to consider all the other things like holsters, spare mags and and sight changes you would want when looking into price.

04-17-2011, 11:57 PM	#10
Barcode Adjusting to the Life Join Date: May 2010 First Name: Tom Location: Everett, WA Posts: 477 Trading: (16)	Re: Opinion on these Handguns I have 2 XD's one 45 and one 40 and love them both. Have never had a problem with either one.

04-18-2011, 12:10 AM	#11
Bill86 Snob Join Date: Jul 2010 First Name: Bill Posts: 6,704 Trading: (67)	Re: Opinion on these Handguns I personally hate the glock frame more than life itself. They were not meant to be held by the human hand. The best thing to do though is either shoot each of them or at least go to a gun shop and decided which fits your hands best.

04-18-2011, 02:33 AM	#12
Bunker New hardware installed. Join Date: Sep 2010 First Name: Rick Location: Moonbatachusetts Posts: 950 Trading: (18)	Re: Opinion on these Handguns I am not a fan or any of the pin fired guns, I want to see a hammer and appreciate the old school mechanics involved. But, if I had to chose one of your three it would be Glock (but I would go with the 19). __________________ "Good is good, even if no one is doing it - and wrong is wrong, even if everyone is doing it."

04-18-2011, 04:53 AM	#13
MiamiE I'm nuts for the place Join Date: Feb 2009 First Name: Erick Location: Miami, FL Posts: 2,892 Trading: (38)	Re: Opinion on these Handguns I grew up firing Glocks. It's what I know and love. Havent shot myself yet! I would go with a compact model as well. Glock 19. The G17 is a beast. Go with the G19 (9mm) or the G23 (.40).

04-18-2011, 06:06 AM	#15
Eleven Solid As The Sun Join Date: Aug 2009 First Name: Scott Location: SW Ohio Posts: 1,859 Trading: (23)	Re: Opinion on these Handguns This poll is invalid without the "All of the above" choice __________________ CA: putting the 'man' in bromance since 2008! --markem.

04-18-2011, 06:20 AM	#16
captain53 Have My Own Room Join Date: Jul 2009 First Name: Dave Location: Lake of the Ozarks & Austin, TX Posts: 1,333 Trading: (3)	Re: Opinion on these Handguns Depends on which one fits your hand and operates in a way that feels comfortable to you. Even though I am not an M&P fan they are all good quality but the one that fits me may not fit you so my preference does not matter.

04-18-2011, 06:57 AM	#19
elderboy02 Lets Go Buckeyes! Join Date: Oct 2008 First Name: Dan Location: Cincinnati, OH Posts: 12,496 Trading: (133)	Re: Opinion on these Handguns I love my Glock's. I will say though, that I have a S&W M&P 9mm and it is phenomenal. Just as good as my Glock. Rent both at a local range and see which one suits you better

04-18-2011, 07:15 AM	#20
HollywoodQue Invictus Join Date: Oct 2010 First Name: Howard Location: In the "D" Posts: 3,119 Trading: (46)	Re: Opinion on these Handguns I was issued the Glock almost 12 years ago and then, I thought this was one of the better semi-auto's out there.....BUT, we Detroit Police Dept, changed over to the S&W MP40 and I love it. I have shot expert with the Glock since I was issued it back in 1997, usually scoring no less than 237 out of 250. Since changing to the M&P, my highest score was 249 out of 250. I love the interchangable hand grips and my groups are more consistence. I vote for the S&W MP all day. Just my