C.A.O. America potomac

I have enjoyed most of the CAO sticks that I have had. This was one of the few that I did not like. I didnt like this and the saprano. I thought the saprano was maybe a $5 stick at best. Way over priced but there your paying for the name. I was excited to try this one and it was a huge let down. Great review again!

Someone must have a positive review of this cigar..? I can't believe that it is universally hated (or at least disliked) by all cigar enthusiasts that have tried it.

I have heard several guys at the shop talk about how much they like it. I do not recall any specifics, however they have been positive.

[Don Fernando]

Philip, trust me, this one had more time than 4 months, at least 2 and a half years, and it still sucked.

Originally Posted by BTcigars

The cigar that a lot of BOTL's save for a American holiday (e.g. 4th of July) is the Camacho Liberty, which is a much more enjoyable smoke.

The Liberty actually took the foul taste of the CAO America out of my mouth and saved the 4th of July American stick theme for me.

Originally Posted by Don Fernando

Philip, trust me, this one had more time than 4 months, at least 2 and a half years, and it still sucked.

Originally Posted by Don Fernando

Philip, trust me, this one had more time than 4 months, at least 2 and a half years, and it still sucked.

That's so odd. This tells me that the manufacturing of the cigar is not consistent. Quality control is lax.
I believe you. They probably spend more time worrying about the pin stripe than the ingredients.