Could cigar ratings be likened to wines?

[markem]

Originally Posted by UPHOTO

I'm not only saying that magazine type reviews are wrong but that would also include individual ones.

A review is, by definition, a personal opinion. Ergo, they can't be wrong as long as they convey the belief of the reviewer.

Not to jump on you too hard, but statements like yours are very uninformed and biased in, well, amazing ways. Many, many here at CA suffer from this, so you are, at least in the opinion of some, in good company.