What is the oldest cigar you have ever smoked?

[shilala]

Originally Posted by icehog3

I also smoked (in a P-P-P) a couple 100 year old cigars over the past couple years. Though the fact that they were still in smokable condition and actually had some flavor aside from "musty" was amazing, and it was cool in a "novelty" kind of way.....but they would rank anywhere near the top (or middle) of great cigars I have smoked.

Did you mean "near the top" or "not near the top"?
I have honestly not had a bad old one. They all smoked great and didn't stink, fall apart, and none were musty like you'd expect.
They have all been as good or better constructionwise than anything I can buy today. That's something special in itself, I think.
It's a LOT of work keeping cigars in good shape for 10 years let alone 50 or 100. It really says something. Not sure what, but it's gotta say something.