Recommendations for iPhone 4s case

[massphatness]

This meets none of your criteria but my Otterbox Defender case is the nuts. I NEVER worry about my phone.
Posted via Mobile Device

[MajorCaptSilly]

Originally Posted by massphatness

This meets none of your criteria but my Otterbox Defender case is the nuts. I NEVER worry about my phone.
Posted via Mobile Device

I use the Otterbox Commuter. It's like the defender in a light version. I can still carry the phone in my pocket with no problem but have some good protection.

MCS

[Sauer Grapes]

Originally Posted by MajorCaptSilly

I use the Otterbox Commuter. It's like the defender in a light version. I can still carry the phone in my pocket with no problem but have some good protection.

MCS

I used to use the commuter. The 3gs version was my favorite case every. The iphone 4 version just didn't work for me. The piece for the top was sharp to my ear, the earphone plug hole was too small for aftermarket headphones, it broke within a few months, etc.

I will say that they sent me a replacement no questions asked, but I just didn't like it for the iphone 4.