What should I try next?

[Kreth]

Originally Posted by kelmac07

Jeff...sorry for the fat fingers...LFD Chisel Maduro is a new fav for me.

No worries... I should have Googled chisel + cigar instead of LFC. I have a spreadsheet from a list Coz77 (I think) posted to a cheap cigars thread. I've modified it to keep track of which cigars I've tried with notes and ratings. This thread has been really helpful for finding similar cigars to what I already know I like.