Where do I go next? Smooth but flavorful

[Porch Dweller]

You might try picking up some samplers from some of the online retailers. They're a great way to try a wide variety of smokes at a reasonable cost. When I started getting serious about cigars I ordered a ton of samplers. It helped me realize what I liked and just as importantly what I didn't like.

If you haven't ordered online before, just be aware that you'll want the cigars to rest in your humidor for at least a month or so before firing them up. This is because they usually ship the cigars a little on the "wet" side.