Originally Posted by EEE
#9 (box press)
I instantly think Mayorga when I pull out this small ring gauged box pressed stick. Though I personally don't know if they come in wrappers outside of jet black - which this one wasn't.
Pre-draw - rich tobacco & bitter on the back of my tongue
Initial light - nice. Interesting coffee and dark dark chocolate taste - that definitely coincides with my pre-draw taste.
First third - the ash is super weak on this, falls off at a butterfly's wing flap. Taste has subdued considerably but still get the dark chocolate undertone.
Second third - good burn, horrid ash, becoming less and less chocolate and more bitter.
Last third - purge, draw, ash fall, taste burnt chocolate, repeat ......... though I must have been hypnotized as I literally nubbed this thing down as far as I could go. Hmmm.
Maybe I have two sides of my smoking brain fighting each other on this. One side isn't impressed at all with the ash and just wants to trash it, doesn't like the burnt chocolate -- but the other side finds it interesting and wants to continue to see where it goes......
I'm not sure I'd buy this cigar but definitely would smoke it again if gifted.
Quote:
Originally Posted by andysutherland
Cigar #9
Construction: 5.5 x42 box-pressed (very square), dark brown wrapper
Pre-light: I honestly forgot to do a pre-light draw.
1st Third: The first bit tasted both bitter and like plain old tobacco. The bitterness remained, but a dark coffee flavor was detectable.
2nd Third: Still bitterness. Dark coffee is behind the bitterness. A nutty flavor is detectable near the end of the second third. Some sort of bitter nut.
Final Third: Still bitter. The nutty flavor is still there, and the coffee returns. Bitterness, nuttiness, and black coffee.
Final Thoughts: The cigar had a bitter taste in the forefront the entire time. The coffee and nutty flavors were nice, but they were behind the bitter flavor. This appearance of this cigar was very attractive, but the bitterness left a bad taste in my mouth.
Would I buy this cigar again? I'd be willing to give it a second shot, as the bitterness may have been exclusive to this single stick.
We had about the same experience with this stick.
Sorry you guys didn't enjoy cigar #9. This is one that I've liked, and picked up a box of the coronas. Not my favorite size, but was hoping they would work for this review. On cbid, when someone says,"mmmmmmmmmmmm...." they are referring to cigar #9:
Estaban Carrera (picture is of natural, the reviewed cigar was a maduro).