I really like the Glenlivet quite a bit - the rest I haven't tried yet.
I have found that I love all of the Islay Single malts... The smoky malt taste of them suits my palate perfectly. My of my favorites (which isn't sold in Michigan since May) is Dalmore Cigar Malt - the perfect taste with almost any good cigar! I'm searching in nearby states to see if they stock the Cigar Malt... it would be worth a road trip to pick up a few bottles!
That is a very nice sampler! I only wish I had a sister like yours!!!