[mhailey]

I hate to be the Devil's advocate but did he say no claims or clean car fax? If just clean car fax, is it actually clean? Run it yourself. If your car fax report is not clean there could be fraud. If it is clean how did he lie or defraud you? What damages have you suffered through his nondisclosure? It is a used car with a $2500 repair. That is a rather nominal repair. A dented fender could be $2500. Is it bad form on his part? Absolutely! I don't know if you have a legal case though.