Good looking pipe.
If you want, I'd suggest the following tobaccos to go with your pipe, all ordered from the same place.
A Virginia sampler (the Hearth & Home Stuff is excellent) Steve B's VA Elite - Hearth & Home Sampler
http://www.pipesandcigars.com/stbsvaelheho.html
I'd also suggest some English (sic) blend [that is, something with Latakia] I'd suggest a couple ounces of Gawith, Hoggarth & Co. Bulk #12 Mixture, as personally that is one of the quintessential English/Latakia blends
http://www.pipesandcigars.com/12mixture.html
An you have already tried a long-standing Burley blend.
Unless of course you want to do the Frog. Oh, just so you know, the McClelland bulk #5110 is very similar to the regular Frog Morton. In fact, most people cannot tell the difference. (just thought that tidbit might be interesting) In the same way, #2035 is hardly discernable from Dark Star.
I think that would keep you around $80.00 or so. Although, if you can kick it up over $100 (just barely) you qualify for free shipping.