Quote:
Originally Posted by icehog3
I just review cigars on flavor, construction, etc by describing them. Never saw any need to attach a number scale.  |
Thank you.
Any review is subjective with regard to flavor, strength, aroma, quality and overall impression. Even external factors such as ambient temperature and humidity, the choice of an accompanying beverage, and even mood influence the outcome.
Any number scale, even CA/CI's—which I do respect and take into account, is an attempt to substantiate a subjective experience.
I'd much rather hear how the cigar tasted to the reviewer; what it felt like, did it hold up all the way through,
is it a cigar of quality—should I bother with it?
Plus, I've read reviews, even those of people whose opinions I respect, and seen a cigar they evidently they did NOT enjoy get scores of 7/10 or even 8/10. It just all seems skewed when you try to quantify the enjoyment in numbers.