[XTRazzer]

I think some of the opinions depend upon where geographically people are located. If in a warmer climate, the wine fridge cooling ability becomes a necessity for some that don't have a basement or other location to keep temperatures low. If in an area of frequent climate change, the coolidor or wine fridge seem to remain more stable than a traditional humidor.

There is something about the elegance of a wood desktop humidor that can't be replaced. But from an economical point of view the coolidor holds more for less money.