20+ years for me.
I've gravitated more towards CC's in the last few months, so they'd top my list:
Partagas Mille Fleurs
Punch RS #12
Monte #4
and still exploring others...haven't had a bad one yet.
NC's still on my radar:
Perdomo Champagne (if and when I can find them)
RP Vintage & Fusion
Taboo Twists (and others)
Funny how my more expensive tastes began at about the same time you got back into cigars a bit more heavily. Coinkidink? I think not.
