[croatan]

As Peter wrote, it's pretty hard to tell what a naked cigar is from pictures. That being said, the pictures and review remind me of a JFR Maduro--though I don't think they've been around as long as most fifth graders. But I do know of some...less scrupulous...vendors who've relabeled them as custom rolls in the past.

Regardless of what it was, though, good job on a blind review, especially for your first one!