For me I dislike any cutter that isn't a punch
Fool proof cutter.
I kid, I try other cutters but this one just seems a bit too gimmicky. I don't even really like the marketing, "helps you control the draw". I dunno how that makes any sense, maybe It's just me. But they do like to say it quite often. They don't even really explain how or why this MIGHT be possible.
To sum it up Mario, I think everyone is only judging it to say "I won't buy this". If these were somehow made available to try......I could see myself using it once or twice out of curiosity. I'm sure most others would try it out as well.
Or like you said if they were free with a purchase......
But as far as shelling out the $40+ these were commanding (for the non-crappy plastic model) I think most people like the tried and true cutters they already have.
Also I gather this thing isn't exactly as compact as a Palio or Xikar punch.
EDIT
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b5duc...eature=related Watch that
. Notice how he misspelled the name of it in the video upload
Bonus points. Again I cannot trust a product with that kinda marketing....