Well the time has come to reveal. Over on cbid, Jimbud made a guess that the cigar was a Joyo de Nicaragua Dark Corojo Antano.
Jim was right!
This cigar was gifted for the lineup by my JdN and Drew Estate rep, Sam (gunbuyer). I'd like to thank Sam for helping out and wanting to be involved in my blind taste test. If you ever get the chance to make a event that Sam is running, it is a good time,and well worth it. Sam is a book of knowledge on cigars if you have any questions.