Hiya, Brent! I don't smoke a large selection of NCs anymore, but when I did, I really liked this site for samplers.
http://www.newhavanacigars.com/
Limited marcas, but many people here like those sticks, so if something looks interesting to you, asking about the sticks in the sampler would produce some very good input.
The NST is amazing and more then worth it both for the stick selection and the many fine friends that you will make.
