Shilala Beads or Puck-ifier?
 

Im about to order one or the other and am up in the air---oddly enough the two different companys are very different in how to charge and care for the beads....help

Re: Shilala Beads or Puck-ifier?
 

Can't go wrong with either Heartfelt of Shilala Beads. A little reading around here will give you the information you need to make your decision. :tu

Re: Shilala Beads or Puck-ifier?
 

I have both and when I make another purchase I will be sticking with the Shilala HCM beads.

Re: Shilala Beads or Puck-ifier?
 

Shilala!

They come precharged and you just put them in!
I have had mine for months with no fluctuation in RH.
And I intend to purchase more! Can't beat Shilala IMO!

Re: Shilala Beads or Puck-ifier?
 

I need to order some more since I'm thinking about getting another cooler. There's a group buy going on right now.

http://www.cigarasylum.com/vb/showthread.php?t=50998

Re: Shilala Beads or Puck-ifier?
 

I'm obviously slanted, but just wanted to say that I have a humidor that has a puckifier built right into the lid and it worked great while I used it. It's a super cool invention and it's nice that you can velcro it right to the lid in your humi. They're versatile.
When the beads in the puckifier wore out and got crumbly and stinky, I just went with soft beadsticks. They're still going strong. :tu

Re: Shilala Beads or Puck-ifier?
 

Only after you've been drinking!

Re: Shilala Beads or Puck-ifier?
 

Ok so im gonna get shilala beads but i should still season the new humi the same way right?

Re: Shilala Beads or Puck-ifier?
 

You should always season your humidor. And I have to agree with the beads.

Re: Shilala Beads or Puck-ifier?
 

Shilala beads.

Re: Shilala Beads or Puck-ifier?
 

Shilala

Re: Shilala Beads or Puck-ifier?
 

Shilala or Heartfelt :tu

Re: Shilala Beads or Puck-ifier?
 

beads.

i own both shilala and HF and both are great.

Re: Shilala Beads or Puck-ifier?
 

:tpd:

Beads--I had wildly fluctuating RH UNTIL I started using Scott's Beads. Had them for years and they still are working great. I had the other and they started to break up and make a real mess.

Shilala HCM Beads :tu

Re: Shilala Beads or Puck-ifier?
 

Shilala for me. I also use them in my guitar case for humidification.

Re: Shilala Beads or Puck-ifier?
 

Its only shilala beads in my cooler and humidor...rock solid!