Cigar Asylum Cigar Forum

Cigar Asylum Cigar Forum (http://www.cigarasylum.com/vb/index.php)

- Island (The other ones) Reviews (http://www.cigarasylum.com/vb/forumdisplay.php?f=13)

- - Brick House (http://www.cigarasylum.com/vb/showthread.php?t=23610)

Maker: Fabrica de Tabacos San Rafael
Distributor: J.C. Newman Cigar Co.
Release Date: September 2009
Filler/Binder/Wrapper: Nicaragua
Vitola: Robusto (5x54)

From the Brick House website:
The original Brick House cigars were Cuban puros, handmade with the finest Havana tobaccos. Third-generation cigar makers, Eric and Bobby Newman, have recreated this vintage cigar brand by blending specially aged Nicaraguan tobaccos with hearty Havana Subido wrapper leaves to match the rich, well-balanced flavor of their grandfather’s Brick House cigars.

From Cigar Insider:
A resurrected vintage brand once made by the Newmans in Cleveland, Brick House is back and now made in the same factory as the company’s El Baton cigar. It is priced for the recession, offering value and flavor. Average Rating (vertical brand tasting) = 88.8

I was gifted this cigar at last week’s herf by Winstonshumidor (thanks, Kevin!) Decided to torch it up on this dreary Saturday afternoon and share my thoughts with CA.

http://i262.photobucket.com/albums/i...BrickHouse.jpg

http://i262.photobucket.com/albums/i...se/BH_foot.jpg

Appearance/Construction
The wrapper on this was smooth & silky, slightly oily and virtually vein-free. There seemed to be one prominent stem just below the surface, but it didn’t affect the cigar. The tobacco at the foot was bunched nicely. The band caught my eye: the artwork was simple, and the colors & font gave it a vintage Victorian look. The draw was easy, the cigar put out copious smoke, the burn was sharp, never needed a touch-up and the ash held well for about 1½” at a time.

Flavor
The first third was consistent, mostly dusty earth and spice, with a nice sweet cedar finish. About midway, a raisin fruitiness came forward and the underlying profile reminded me of a toasted bagel. I could snork the smoke with just a little pinch in the sinuses. The body was on the full side of medium, and I could feel the strength starting to slowly build.

http://i262.photobucket.com/albums/i...se/BH_burn.jpg

About midway I added a rootbeer accompaniment, and the two paired well: the creamy sweetness offset the dry earthiness of the smoke. The last half of the cigar picked up in complexity and was very enjoyable. At times it reminded me of a Tatuaje Noellas: complex mixture of flavors—earthy, cedar, and hints of grilled steak, with a fruity finish. A mouth coating, tingly spice returned in the last third to really make things interesting.

http://i262.photobucket.com/albums/i.../BH_smokin.jpg

Overall
I did not know anything about this cigar before Kevin gifted it, including the price. After my smoking session, I would have guessed this was an $8-9 cigar, and was pleased to learn MSRP on the whole line is at about $5. This was a surprisingly good smoke. Construction was top notch, and I particularly enjoyed the flavor complexity in the second half. Definitely an outstanding value.

http://i262.photobucket.com/albums/i...use/BH_nub.jpg

Thanks for the reivew! I've been trying to find me one of these and your review just makes me wanna try harder! Thanks!

Thanks for the review! I picked up a corona today and I can't wait to fire one up.

Thanks for the review and pic's Gerard!

I gotta agree with you, I didn't want to like it (being a Fuente product) but was pleasantly surprised how good it is and like Danny said, it's got a great price point!

Quote:

Originally Posted by SkinsFanLarry (Post 615784)

It's not a Fuente product.

Quote:

Originally Posted by NCRadioMan (Post 615791)

It's not a Fuente product.

It's made by the same people that make the El Baton. Isn't that a Pepin product??

Quote:

Originally Posted by kelmac07 (Post 615801)

It's made by the same people that make the El Baton. Isn't that a Pepin product??

It's JC Newman. We did an event last month with these and it was a big hit.

Quote:

Originally Posted by kaisersozei (Post 615692)

Maker: Fabrica de Tabacos San Rafael
Distributor: J.C. Newman Cigar Co.
Release Date: September 2009
Filler/Binder/Wrapper: Nicaragua
Vitola: Robusto (5x54)

Got it...reading is fundamental!!! :tu

Quote:

Originally Posted by NCRadioMan (Post 615791)

It's not a Fuente product.

Ok, you're right.....it's part of the "Cigar Family" which is a partnership of Fuente and J.C. Newman.

But like you said it is solely made by J.C. Newman.

(J.C. Newman is the world-wide distributor for Arturo Fuente cigars)

Great review, I just picked up one yesterday.

Another fine review, Gerard. Thanks!

Sounds like an interesting smoke.

Did you listen to the song "Brick House" while smoking it? :D

Hopefully will be trying one soon ,been hearing good things about this one!

I missed an event for these at my B&M a short while ago. Maybe there will be a couple in my locker when I get back.

I wasn't interested in trying them until this review, now I must.

I've heard a few great reviews of this stick, at $5 it sounds like a big winner

Nice review. My B&M just started carrying these as well as the El Baton cigars. I'll have to pick up a few and try em.

Quote:

Originally Posted by elderboy02 (Post 615781)

Thanks for the review! I picked up a corona today and I can't wait to fire one up.

:tpd: Me too! Well, it's yesterday now. :ss

I may have smoked it too soon. I may have gotten a bad stick. I was less than enthralled with mine. Not bad mind you, just a very herbal character throughout, which doesn't really suit my tastes.

I had a robusto that was fantastic and after researching on their website, each size has its own flavor profile. That makes me want to pick up one of each size for a side by side comparison.

They have these at TampaHumidor for under $5 for the Robusto and Corona and w/free shipping for single don't know how you can lose here. I am going to order both of these along with some others I have had my eye on. I love not having to pay S/H.