Cigar Asylum Cigar Forum - What Is My Favorite Cigar?

Cigar Asylum Cigar Forum (http://www.cigarasylum.com/vb/index.php)

- General Discussion (http://www.cigarasylum.com/vb/forumdisplay.php?f=48)

- - What Is My Favorite Cigar? (http://www.cigarasylum.com/vb/showthread.php?t=70283)

What Is My Favorite Cigar?

Everybody always asks what you guy's favorite cigar is.
I'd like to know what MY favorite cigar is.
I'll give you a hint...
It's not a Party short.

Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?

Padron?

Oh sorry, I meant Patron.

Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Poet (Post 2055005)

Padron?

Oh sorry, I meant Patron.

NO.
There will be no parting gift or door prize. Just go home.
Next?

Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?

I had no idea this would be so much fun!!! :lr

Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?

Whichever one you are smoking at the time?

Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?

Not even close, John. I throw cigars away all the time cause they suck.

Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?

One that you smoked with your son(s)...or father?

Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?

Negative.
This is not a trick question or anything.

Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chainsaw13 (Post 2055023)

Plpc

I think Bob's winning so far.
I do love anything PL. Except the RE's.
Probably my favorite marca.

Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?

Quote:

Originally Posted by shilala (Post 2055039)

I think Bob's winning so far.

I demand a recount!

Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Poet (Post 2055042)

I demand a recount!

No way, Cracker. :lr

Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?

Back in '08-09, I had a clear and decisive favorite.
Two, actually. Both were NC's.

That's kind of misleading, cause I think they stopped making one around '05, but I busted my ass to corner the market and bought every single one I could. PapaJohn liked the counterpart to the one I liked, it was his favorite.
He had to stop smoking because of his health and we don't see him anymore, he is very sorely missed.
One time Vin bought me a couple boxes of those delectable first faves, and that was the final nail. I smoked a zillion of them, and I absolutely loved them.
Then Cigars International bought the brand and turned them into doo.
That's good clues.

The cc side is tough, but I can tell you that the very best cc I have ever smoked, DaKlugs Dave shared with me at Shack.
An old PL Magnum.
I have been blessed to smoke literally everything, and that cigar was far and away the very best by a long margin.

But I only really smoke pedestrian cc's. At least to the tune of plain old off the shelf stuff. No RE's or LE's. So that really narrows that side.

Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?

Padron 1926 #6 maduro

Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?

DPG JJ Series Maduro

Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Poet (Post 2055055)

Bahia?

Lol. Really?

Quote:

Originally Posted by big_jaygee (Post 2055056)

Padron 1926 #6 maduro

That was the cigar that blew the whole cigar world open for me.
Still love them, but not my favorite.

Quote:

Originally Posted by kelmac07 (Post 2055057)

DPG JJ Series Maduro

That was one of the old nc's. You should know the other one, too.

Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?

Quote:

Originally Posted by shilala (Post 2055058)

Lol. Really?

Yeah, really. Yanks have no taste, and neither do yanks. :D

Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?

Lol. Still, Bahia?
Why not Quorum?

Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?

A Churchill with Chin nuts?? :sh

Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?

Hey, the old Bahia Brazilian maduros, the ones with the yellow band, weren't half-bad with some age on them.

But yeah, it was a joke.

Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?

Quote:

Originally Posted by shilala (Post 2055058)

That was one of the old nc's. You should know the other one, too.

Those lovely Oliva Blue Cloth band Os... :dr :dr :dr :dr

Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?

Bolivar PC.
I was thinking the Gold Medal until you mentioned "plain old off the shelf stuff"

Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?

Swisher Sweet? :confused: ;s

Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?

Mac got the two nc's. JJ Maduros and Oliva Blues.
Peter, I do love Boli GM's. They're pretty much off the shelf.

Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?

Bolivar CJ or RASCC.

Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?

The best ones I ever had were from '09, if that helps.

Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?

No, but I do like Monte 4's and 5's.

Another clue...
Most guys like the bigger ones from '98. I like 'em too, but they're too rich for my blood.

Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?

Romeo y Julietta Short Churchill

Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?

The NC is Indian Tabac, is it not?
(Disclosure - I remember years ago you did an experiment
with these, and I was one of the guinea pigs)

Oh, never mind, didn't read the prior posts.

Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?

Quote:

Originally Posted by Conch Republican (Post 2055160)

LGC's MdO 2

There ya go. When they're good.
But I ALWAYS love Trini Reyes and PLpc's.