wrapper on or off?
 

Should i leave the wrappers on my cigars when i store them in the humidor or will it dry them out?

Re: wrapper on or off?
 

I smoke my cigars with the wrappers on...now the cello on the other hand...http://www.cigarasylum.com/vb/showth...ighlight=cello;)

Personally, I keep them however I got them.

Re: wrapper on or off?
 

I usually leave them on...I don't think I have any in my Humi right now that's not except that half box of LP#9's...:dr :dr

Re: wrapper on or off?
 

me personally leave it on helps protect if your rough on them

Re: wrapper on or off?
 

You take your wrappers off? :r :r

It's a personal preference on the cello on/cello off debate. I, personally, keep it on so the sticks don't get damaged. :2

Re: wrapper on or off?
 

Wrappers on, cello on and I put my singles in sleeve bags.
This thread makes me smile!

Re: wrapper on or off?
 

I usually leave the wrapper on. Cello is your choice, usually helps to protect and doesn't affect aging.

Re: wrapper on or off?
 

ya i meant cello not wrapper my bad i am new to all of this thanks guys for helping out a newbie i just put my cigars in the humidor the humidity is only reading 64% i so i added a water pillow i hope that brings it up over night

Re: wrapper on or off?
 

bring it up to what?

IMO, I would leave it at 64% and see how you like it.

Re: wrapper on or off?
 

Not going to hurt anything at 64, goes to preference on what rel. humidity smokes best for you(taste, burn, enjoyment, etc...)

Re: wrapper on or off?
 

i was reading it should be between 68% to 72% i wanted to bring it up to somewhere between that

Re: wrapper on or off?
 

you didn't read that here ;)

Re: wrapper on or off?
 

Peter is wise.:D

Re: wrapper on or off?
 

no i did not read that here so many people say so many different things i don't know what to believe like if you should or should not wipe the inside of a new humidor down with distilled water i ended doing so but i heard different opinions on that

Re: wrapper on or off?
 

There are LOTS of stickies here you can read that have a wealth of information. Look in this sub forum and the accessories sub forum.

Re: wrapper on or off?
 

Use the search option here, any questions you have now have probably been asked many times before and answered by the wealth of knowledge from the senior members here in the Asylum like Peter. If you can't find it, were always happy to give smart a$$ answers too...

Re: wrapper on or off?
 

thanks i have learned alot allready in my short time being a memeber here

Re: wrapper on or off?
 

Re: wrapper on or off?
 

Yes, Always feel free to ask the questions you have. The only stupid question is the one never asked. No one is going to flame you for asking something you don't know, or has been asked before. The worse is they might direct you to the search function.

Glad to have you here Mike. :we

Re: wrapper on or off?
 

Damn, I thought this thread was about a completely different subject :)

Re: wrapper on or off?
 

:tpd:

Re: wrapper on or off?
 

I leave the cigars as they come to me.

As for RH 65% is a great place to be at. I believe it was the most popular RH when polled awhile back as well.

Re: wrapper on or off?
 

It's so dry here in Vegas I've found if it's not 68-70+ it's hard to get that nice oily sheen on them and they also start to crack in mid smoke. The air here is a freaking sponge. Suck the life right out of them soon as they come out to play.

When I was in Puerto Rico last month and it was low 80's and 70-80% humidity all the time...wow what a difference. My cigars look "healthy" if you catch my drift. I had a Lot 23 natural that was just shiny and dark, almost like a colorado wrapper. It burned so...damn...slow and the flavors lept out. What a difference.

Re: wrapper on or off?
 

That's a bit on the high side for me, but it really boils down to what humidity range you think your cigars smoke best in, not what others say or think. From a practical standpoint, you don't want to go much below the mid fifties, or the cigar will dry out and lose it's oils. Over seventy, and you risk mold. Anything in between is fair game.


Odd. I keep mine in the low 60's range and seldom have problems with cracking or unraveling. Maybe Henderson is different than Vegas? :r

Re: wrapper on or off?
 

Ask whatever, I'll answer whatever. People direct you to the search function, I like the search for reading reviews, but if I was going to search for an answer to a question, I could use google rendering my membership here useless. So ask anything, worse case scenario, people will send you a link to an old thread.

Also, it's all what you want to do. I leave the cello on for the same reason as everyone else, not as much worry when you transport them and such.

I also like my humidity in the high 60's -70%, so whatever works for you, run with it.

Smoke what you like, like what you smoke.

Re: wrapper on or off?
 

I've found that I enjoy my cigars more when my humi is at around 65% humidity, but I only started smoking this fall (and I live in the Milwaukee area).

I know I stressed out about the cello on/off debate as well, I took pretty much all of the cellos off my first stash, and now I wish I hadn't. Having the cello on them makes it so much easier to move them around, and more importantly give them to other people! :D

Re: wrapper on or off?
 

Recently, I have had two cigars that I did not care for that I SHOULD have really liked.

They both had a flavor profile that I really enjoy.

They were a 601 blue and a joya de Nicaragua.

The 601 had a little bit of flavor but not much. The Joya de Nic had no flavor at all.......none. I smoked the whole thing waiting for some flavor to come out but I got nothing out of it. This was the first smoke I got absolutely no flavor out of.

Both of these had no cellophane wrapper when I received them. They both sat for at least a month or two in my humi before I smoked them.

Coincidence? Maby.

I have another Joya de Nic in my humi with a wrapper on it and I will see how the flavor is in that one sometime here in the future.

I know there are a few duds out there and maby thats what I got and it was just coincidence that neither had a wrapper?

Re: wrapper on or off?
 

No correlation.
And who the heck is Maby?
Posted via Mobile Device

Re: wrapper on or off?
 

Re: wrapper on or off?
 

As Peter said, the cellophane wrapper does not affect the flavor. In fact cellophane is porous so it does not keep anything out (or in). What the cellophane does do is help to protect the cigar during shipping and handling.

Re: wrapper on or off?
 

Sorry for my bad spelling. Maybe

Re: wrapper on or off?
 

Thanks for the information guys, guess I just got some duds.

I would really like to try the 601 blue again as a lot of people here seem to really enjoy them.

;)
Posted via Mobile Device