What cigar ages the longest?
 

Out of all the many kinds of cigars, which one do you think ages the longest for the best taste?

Re: What cigar ages the longest?
 

Stonger oily cigars with a lot of oil.

Re: What cigar ages the longest?
 

I just realized what I typed there... yes I'm redundant.

Re: What cigar ages the longest?
 

Specifically Opus X and Fuente Anejos benefit greatly from age, some of the few NC's that do IMO.

Re: What cigar ages the longest?
 

Thanks for responding. Please keep opinions coming. It is giving us some ideas.

Re: What cigar ages the longest?
 

Who is us? And what are your ideas?

Re: What cigar ages the longest?
 

we are legion, for we are many

Re: What cigar ages the longest?
 

Two people who love woodworking......hehehehe

Re: What cigar ages the longest?
 

We are the world.
We are the children.








We are kumarusc? Or at least a friend of his?

Re: What cigar ages the longest?
 

Thinking about a 10-15 year progressive humidor

Re: What cigar ages the longest?
 

Back to the question at hand, are you refering to CCs or NC? Most any CCs benefit from aging, yet most NCs do not benefit from more than 6 months rest. Some are greatly benefited, such as Darrell's recommendation.

Re: What cigar ages the longest?
 

I'd say the ones that are oldest have probably aged the longest.

If you buy two cigars at the same time, the one you smoke last ages the longest.

It's really not rocket science. :D

Re: What cigar ages the longest?
 

Well that's really not what I was trying to get at rocket science and all. I am new so I am learning some things. I get that it's a difference between NC and CC. I understand that now. That's why we are still learning and thinking about options for storage. But I get what you're saying as well. As I live in Michigan that would make it apparently NC's for us. So, instead of a yearly humi it would be a monthly thing then. Still sits well with the scope of our planning.

Re: What cigar ages the longest?
 

Could you (or "y'all", rather) explain your (or "y'all's", rather) "yearly humi" and "monthly humi" and "progressive humi" ideas to us/me? We/I are/am quite perplexed.

Re: What cigar ages the longest?
 

Whether you are perplexed or not is not my fault. I am on this site as my husband and I enjoy herfing and woodworking and this site was recommended. As it stands now, with responses that put a person on the defensive, I can't say I would recommend this site to anyone.

Thank you to those who have responded trying to help.

Re: What cigar ages the longest?
 

I'm confused as hell with this thread now. :2

Re: What cigar ages the longest?
 

What is a progressive humi?

Re: What cigar ages the longest?
 

:tpd:

Re: What cigar ages the longest?
 

There is popular discussion that says you can have two of the same cigar that will mature differently in a different environment.

put one cigar in a 70/70 environment with lots of open air exchange, it will mature quicker than putting an identical cigar in say a 65/65 environment enclosed in a coffin or tube.

Re: What cigar ages the longest?
 

:confused:

Sorry I am poor dirt farmer from Saskatchewan and I am always eager to learn too...but I can not figure out the monthly/progressive thing either.

I understand the temp/RH/storage type i.e. Cab vs. Dress vs. tubo vs single debated but if you would give me an idea on your humi I would happily post my ideas on aging NCs. Plus I would be happy to refer you to an ECCJ article that is in the most recent issue that talks on this direct.

Re: What cigar ages the longest?
 

The point of the questions was not to put you on the defensive, it was to try to clarify your inquiry in order to give you better information. You will never find a friendlier group than are present on this board.

Re: What cigar ages the longest?
 

:tpd:tpd:
No offense has been intended by anyone I'm sure. We are all harmless and gentle inmates in this asylum. Well, most of us anyways. But those who aren't take medication for it.:D

Re: What cigar ages the longest?
 

I won't apologize for my comedy nor the way I look.

Anyway, my comment wasn't to give you attitude but more to directly answer you question as it was worded. Welcome to CA though. You will find us rather friendly when you get to know us but you need a rather thick skin at times. We are good people.

What were you asking in your original question? The way it is worded leaves a lot open to interpretation of your actual intent. Did you want to know about whether or not a cigar will take longer to age in certain conditions? What do you mean by "age"? Etc.

Re: What cigar ages the longest?
 

:bh

Re: What cigar ages the longest?
 

Why did I avoid clicking on this thread earlier? Gold, Jerry...pure gold!

Re: What cigar ages the longest?
 

Ok, anyone have thoughts on which marcas/vitolas are oily? I see people posting about this but I never find that characteristic in any of the cigars that I smoke.

~Vitis

Re: What cigar ages the longest?
 

Toothy cigars are what I consider oily. The wrapper has that shine to it.

Re: What cigar ages the longest?
 

Toothy refers to a rough looking wrapper. I would not equate toothy with oily/shiny.

Re: What cigar ages the longest?
 

So "toothy" would = a veiny wrapper?

Re: What cigar ages the longest?
 

I think that the OP was referring to a humi with multiple trays/drawers which would allow them to put "Year 1" cigars on one tray, "Year 2" cigars on the next, and progressively through several years so they can always be smoking the oldest cigars. At least that's to what I think she was referring.

Re: What cigar ages the longest?
 

the one that ages the longest is the one not smoked.

Re: What cigar ages the longest?
 

Cigars w/ little bumps all on them are what I consider "Toothy" (correct me if I'm wrong). Most cigars that I have smoked w/ little bumps on them have a sheen to the wrapper. I know this is a nasty cigar, but VS Connecticut Yankee comes to mind. It's "bumpy" and "shiny".

Re: What cigar ages the longest?
 

Cameroon is toothy.

MCS

Re: What cigar ages the longest?
 

this is toothy
http://img406.imageshack.us/img406/4146/toothy03mw7.gif

Re: What cigar ages the longest?
 

Perfect definition. Pink squirrel (or is that a pink beaver) cigars are toothy. :tu

Re: What cigar ages the longest?
 

"Tooth".......
those tiny little bumps characteristic to certain types of cigar wrappers. Camaroon (sp?) normally has a lot of tooth.
"Toothy" does not mean a "rough" wrapper.

As far as some examples of NC cigars that age well, the Dominican Davidoff line ages well, as does Opus X, Don Carlos, Padron Anniversarios, and a few others.
Hope this helps.