Difference between spice and pepper?
 

Ok gang,

I have been wondering about this for some time and have not found a definitive answer...so...what is the difference between spice and pepper as they relate to cigars? Would I confuse spice/pepper as harshness, as a noob? (I think I am)

Does spice also include things like nutmeg, cinnamon, ect, or just a spicy burn, tingle on the tounge? How do I tell pepper from harshness?

I hear a lot of talk about the DGP smokes (DPG Ho tread), they mention a typical spice/pepper. I want to try some of these smokes as a LOT of you seem to like them. I am a little afraid of the pepper/spice 'blast' as I don't really like the 'harsh/hot' thing. It kept me from enjoying cigars for a long time, as I was trying to avoid this harsh/hot smoke thing.

Skool time!!

Re: Difference between spice and pepper?
 

spice includes nutmeg, cinnamon...but read between the lines. i think its important to go into a little detail when you review a cigar. you can differentiate between sweet/"hot"/exotic spices...
i have never had a dpg but from the reviews that i read they have typically a pepper note in them.
Go to your b+m buy one and decide if you like it or not. If you dont like it revisit dpg sticks after a couple of months.

Re: Difference between spice and pepper?
 

Personally, I tend to get black peper from a lot of DPG's sticks. Some sticks are more heavy with this flavor than others. A good tip for someone new into cigars is to try and slow down your smoking. Taking longer breaks in-between puffs, and sipping instead of trying to get a ton of smoke on each draw might help with the harsh/hot factor. It took me a long time to actually apply that technique. I still tend to smoke cigars I really like too fast, but it gives me an excuse to practice smoking more cigars. :D

Other cigars that just mention pepper could also be refering to red peppers, green peppers...etc.

I tend to pick up some red pepper taste from Taboo special forces blends that will leave a tingle on the lips.

Bottom line is taste are subjective, and eveyone will enjoy different cigar profiles. The sweetness of maduros, the black pepper of DPG's, they all depend on what your in the mood for.

Enjoy the adventure, and try as many differnt cigars as you can. A cigar you hate today maybe your best friend a year from now. :tu

Re: Difference between spice and pepper?
 

When I write 'spice' in reviews I mean green spices like parsley, coriander and so on. When I write pepper, I mean pepper like black pepper or white pepper. Sometimes, when the flavor is easy noticeable, I even write which kind of pepper I taste. If I taste cinnamon, I will write I taste cinnamon, I am unable to notice the difference between the green spices, so when I taste them I name them "spice"

Re: Difference between spice and pepper?
 

I would have never guessed that. herb might be a better word to describe these flavours!

Re: Difference between spice and pepper?
 

Wow,

Who knew how many flavors the word spice might encompass. I never considered the green/red pepper thing also. Hmmmmm.... or the green spice-which I believe I have experianced before, think I called it grassy. So much to learn...need to smoke more!!

My nearest B & M has not had any DPG's for several weeks. Guess I'll have to keep stopping in to check. I'll let ya all know how the lessons progress.

Tim L.

Re: Difference between spice and pepper?
 

He said herb. hee-hee
Thats not a flavor I expected. :ss




Actually, I never considered this either
Tim L.

Re: Difference between spice and pepper?
 

my 2 cents:

I do not like peppery tastes in cigars....I consider pepper to be the harsh taste that hits the back of my throat... Itell people, "this smoke is peppery". Sometimes i confuse a peppery taste for a a fuller body, soemtimes the peppery taste makes me feel like i did the first time i smoked a full body smoke.



Now,

I DO like spicey notes in a cigar. Spice (to me) usually takes place on my actual pallate. Like PMWZ said, spice is more of a nutmeggy-cinnamon taste and a lot of the times when i smoke a spicey cigar the spice is usually preluded by a leathery taste (which i love) or followed with a leathery tastes. this is purely a correlary (sp). I love those types of cigars in general. Bucanero has a double maduro house blend that is to die for that exhibits what i consider to be the "quintessential" spice (accompanied by leather) taste.

If you would like to try one just let me know, I'd gladly buy you a couple and send them to you.

Regardless, all of our pallates are different.

Re: Difference between spice and pepper?
 

Just my two cents.

For me I never use the word spice in describing the tastes of a cigar. I use more exact descriptors because typically my European friends mean spice to be nutmeg, cinnamon, and pepper and my American friends mean it to mean peppery or heat based tastes. At least thats the distinction I've noticed.

Re: Difference between spice and pepper?
 

I break it down to two groups:
"Black spice" pepper, ect.
and "sweet spice" cinnamon, ect.

Re: Difference between spice and pepper?
 

All good answers so far. I would say there is a big difference between harshness and pepper/spice though... Harshness usually means its burning too fast but pepper/spice are natural flavors from tobacco

aj

Re: Difference between spice and pepper?
 

WELLLLL, we must all just lack the sophistication you possess!!















Just messing with you!

Re: Difference between spice and pepper?
 

:tpd:

That is almost exactly how I would describe it.

Spice can mean different things to different people. And what one person tastes is not a guarantee of what the next person will taste. I am learning more and more to go ahead and try a cigar for myself, because no one has my tongue and someone's review is their opinion of that cigar.

Re: Difference between spice and pepper?
 

Baking spices (cinnamon, nutmeg) vs. Pepper spices (white, black, Habanero ;) )

Re: Difference between spice and pepper?
 

Here is the infamous Flavor Wheel. This may help define other flavors you may find.

http://img256.imageshack.us/i/flavorwheel1.pdf/

Re: Difference between spice and pepper?
 

When I think of spice in a cigar, it's that peppery or cayenne flavor. Cinnamon, nutmeg, or whatever else is not spice to me, in a cigar anyway. Kind of like how when someone talks about spicy food, they're usually referring to heat and not something like paprika.
Posted via Mobile Device

Re: Difference between spice and pepper?
 

I'm not the brightest bulb in the pack. I think of it as...

Pepper: Tat T110
Spice: Monte #2

Re: Difference between spice and pepper?
 

Not sophistication at all, it simple effort. When I write a review I always go back and remove spicy as descriptor. The site where I mostly post reviews has a high percentage of Europeans and the term spice carries a different conotation for them.

Re: Difference between spice and pepper?
 

One must flow to keep the universe intact, the other is apart of a 2 girl duo that was frankly horrid.

Re: Difference between spice and pepper?
 

+1

Also, I get the baking spices on the back or sides of my tongue/throat, while most pepper I get is more distinct and usually covers my whole mouth and burns my nose. I can snork "spice" more easily.

Re: Difference between spice and pepper?
 

I get spice from most all my smokes. It's because I like it, and it's what I seek out.
It's sort of the flavor from spice jelly beans that ends up in your sinus. Not the taste (which I hate) but the nuance in my sinus.
Pepper is just that.
I can pick up Black Pepper and White Pepper in cigars.
I don't care for either, but I can tolerate white pepper whereas I absolutely hate cigars that leave a black pepper in my sinus, like DPG Blacks, for instance.
If you've never tried white pepper, it's on most tables at chinese restaurants. It's just like Black Pepper without a smell.
That's my take, for what it's worth. :)

Re: Difference between spice and pepper?
 

:tpd:
The cliff notes version, but these are my thoughts exactly.

Re: Difference between spice and pepper?
 

I say peppery is a flavor, spice the feeling of spiciness, the bite, the tingle. Pepper flavor of course go hand in hand with spicy, but there is a very distinct difference between pepper flavors and spicy feeling, or even spice flavors. Even different types of pepper have different flavors (white, black, red).

Spice FLAVOR, and the fact you are talking about a flavor I believe should be specified, could be cinnamon/nutmeg/clove, and then still be spicy feeling.

Re: Difference between spice and pepper?
 

Wow,

Lots of good info here guys. There seems to be a lot of different opinons as to what the differences are between spice/pepper and that harsh/heat thing.

The flavor wheel is GREAT! It is much more detailed than the one I've seen before. I don't like how close leather (LOVE that flavor in a cigar) is to horse manure and rancid!! :O

I'm going to go back over the info in the thread when I have more time, and try to absorb it better.

Keep the opinions coming, I am finding this VERY helpful.
Heres to you Guys

:wnr


Tim L.

Re: Difference between spice and pepper?
 

I know i already had a response... i'd like to give an example too.


i consider an Oliva V torpedo to be very peppery.

I consider the camacho triple maduro to be very spicey

then again, all of our pallates won't be exactly the same

Re: Difference between spice and pepper?
 

My two cents and then I'll duck. The original question is a good one and should have been asked by all the reviewers and a consensus arrived at before using the term "spice" in reviews. It is fairly obvious to me, from reading this thread, that "spice" is different things to different people and others are just wondering what they are all talking about. It is too general a term and ambiguous so it should not be used without other adjectives to modify it. Green spice is not a good one. As pointed out, green is generally an herb and not a spice. You really should say cinnamon or nutmeg or pepper or coriander or celery or cabbage or pickles if that's what you taste. If you don't know what you taste and have to use spice then you shouldn't be reviewing. I don't review as my palate is not so sophisticated. I think that's not such a bad thing. Sweet, earthy, coffee, mocha, cedar I understand and am happy with those. Acid Cigars are spicy! I know no others and am happy with that. To tell you the truth, I don't know if those "sophisticated palates" are really tasting more that I do or just making it up because they can't really tell what it is. I DO like that "Hmmmmm, wonder what that is?" taste in foods. I don't really have it with cigars and don't know that anyone does. If they do, they don't speak for the majority.