Re: Punch or Cut?
 

Always cut.....

Re: Punch or Cut?
 

99% of the time its cut with my Palio. The other 1% is a punch.

I like to use a punch on the LFD Chisels. Punch all the way through, it's like a completely different smoke when done that way!

Re: Punch or Cut?
 

Mostly V-cut lately.:tu

Re: Punch or Cut?
 

I only cut, I don't even know what happened to my punch cutters after I picked up a palio a few years ago.

Re: Punch or Cut?
 

Punch and Cut, I cant stand the V-Cut

Punch resides on the keyring (cheap punch, but I just loved the .44 mag bullet :P), it only gets used (sometimes) for the larger ring sizes.

cheap cutter for everything else (havn't gotten around to getting a palio yet)

Re: Punch or Cut?
 

I'm using a palio at home or a planned herf. It a cheap punch on the key ring for the cargar.........

Re: Punch or Cut?
 

I always use a cutter (Palio or Xikar). I do not like using a punch.

Re: Punch or Cut?
 

100% Palio, but I'm sure there are a hand full of punches in the junk cabinet.

Re: Punch or Cut?
 

For me it would be a punch for robusto/toro shaped cigars, and a cutter for the rest.

Re: Punch or Cut?
 

I am using the punch more and more. Still use the "V" cutter occasionally too.

Probably like tastes, I am sure I will bounce around between the two.

Re: Punch or Cut?
 

never punched, don't even have a punch

Re: Punch or Cut?
 

Pair of punches showed up today that I ordered to play with. Cut my first cigar with the Palio last night, that was nice. Been cutting so far.

Re: Punch or Cut?
 

I used to punch, then I got a Palio...

Re: Punch or Cut?
 

I used to punch, but now i cut everytime. The key is to just take of the top cap, and see that nice divot left behind.

Re: Punch or Cut?
 

I have a punch, but it gets less use than my Xikar. I have punched maybee three or four smokes, but I prefer to use my Palio for everything. I would punch a chisel, but I rarley smoke them.

Re: Punch or Cut?
 

I have a triple flame Colibri with a punch attached on the bottom.....never really cared for it but convenient as hell....just got a Palio....now its cut, cut, cut....

Re: Punch or Cut?
 

Cut with my trusty Palio, everytime...

Re: Punch or Cut?
 

I'll do whatever it takes to get the cigar smoked. If I have a cutter near me, I'll use it. If not, I'll use whatever I can get my hands on. I don't normally bite the end off my cigar, but I'm not at all adverse to the idea.
I have a v cutter I've never used, and in the past I carried a lighter with a punch.
I mostly use one of my Xikars.

Re: Punch or Cut?
 

Re: Punch or Cut?
 

Punch on the short fillers and a cutter on everone else.