Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

I would like to be part of a group buy on this.I could go as high as $150.It seems like a good idea to me.:D

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

I would like to get in on a club pipe, just as long as the price is less than $130. I would prefer to have a rusticated pipe with some kind of bend.

Seth

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

I am not interested in any pipe group buys anymore, but I do have a few pieces of advice for you guys.

First, make sure that the carver that you choose has done group pipes before. Dealing with someone that has never done it before or has little experience dealing with a group's expectations is very frustrating. Especially if the pipes don't meet the group's expectations in quality or appearance once completed.

Next, if you are going to pick a shape before an artisan, make sure that the artisan is comfortable with the shape that you picked and has made it before. It is probably safer to choose the maker and then pick a shape that they make pretty often with possibly some tweaks. It may not be as special or unique, but everyone ends up happy with the quality, appearance and construction.

Lastly, picking a new or up and coming pipe maker can seem attractive due to price or other considerations, but going with one of the more established pipe makers is always a better choice. Even if they may be a bit more expensive, it is worth it to know you are going to get a quality product and if you aren't happy they will make it right. A couple good ones that I can think of off the top of my head would be Tinsky and Boswell.

Good luck to you guys.

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

thanks for the advice Sawyer

I would like to have Tinsky do it, but I doubt he could fit our budget. Boswell is probably the best candidate for price, but they are overwhelmed at the moment, so I don't know how soon they could be done.

I'll probably start sending out some emails next week to see who would even be interested, and figure out a shape and all that from there.

judging from this thread, I think I'll first ask about 1/4 bent poker, then maybe a bent apple.

If whoever picks us up can't/won't/doesn't like doing pokers, would you guys prefer an apple, lovat, or maybe even a dublin

let me know, I think the first round of emails will be to: Boswell, Senatorov, and Kirk Bosi (did the club pipe for IPC last year with great results)

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

I'd still prefer the finished apple in a dark, RX.

But, an unfinished Lovat does look nice as I now look at them, not knowing what they were.

Good luck to you, and thanks for doing this! :)

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

I want to be a pain; my updated choices are below.

1. rx2010 ($80-130)
2. JaKaacH ($79-129)
3. Nabinger16 ($81-131)
4. sixpacksunday ($79.50-130.50) pinching pennies!
5. Yellowgoat (up to 130)
6. Savvy (up to 130+)
7. KZM007 ($50 - $130)
8. WWhermit ($50-$150)

I like the idea of a bent or straight finished apple pipe.

I also found some interest in an unfinished/rustic Lovat pipe.

Lastly, as Requiem stated, a churchwarden would give CA a classy sort of appeal for a first pipe, and I really like Zeman's Lord of the Pipe as well as his corkscrew stem on the Fiery Cross model.

Sorry to be such a bother; the more I look, the more I like. No more choices lol.

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

looks like we've got 16 or so that would be interested.

I forgot about Zeman, I will include him in the first round of emails

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

I would probably be interested in getting in on this as well. Will keep an eye on this to see where it goes.

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

1. rx2010 ($80-130)
2. JaKaacH ($79-129)
3. Nabinger16 ($81-131)
4. sixpacksunday ($79.50-130.50) pinching pennies!
5. Yellowgoat (up to 130)
6. Savvy (up to 130+)
7. KZM007 ($50 - $130)
8. WWhermit ($50-$150)
9. RGD ($49.95)

:D Price ranges are fine with me. More of a bent apple kinda guy here - with a really big bowl.


Ron

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

maybe its time to add a poll or two?

i would prefer a bent apple myself as well, but have no problems with what the majority agrees to.

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

I am interested... similar range to the posted ones

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

I'd be willing to do this too!

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

I posted in the poll, just wanted to make it official, I'm interested :dance:

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

just a sugestion on the cheap side: Jirsa pipes (Czech Rep.)

http://www.jirsa.cz/home/index-en.html
http://www.jirsa.cz/shopcz/mypage/index.html


(note: 1000 CKZ = less $50)

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

wow, there are some seriously beautiful pipes there

anyone have any experience with these?

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

found this about them: http://forum.pipes.org/~discus/discu...tml?1154113083

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

hmmm, I'll keep an eye out on those, but tomorrow evening I will email the aforementioned makers

today was a bit unexpected, so I didn't accomplish much

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

Just an unofficial vote: I REALLY like Jirsa's work, especially the grain on a number of his pieces.

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

I wasnt too partial to the ones on his site, but this one on fleabay has really nice grain.

The price direct from him is attractive too, but I would rather pay a bit more if the quality is going to be more consistent (some of the comments on pipes.org indicated offcenter draft hole, etc.).

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

any news on this?

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

actually no, I have been swamped, but I have spring break next week, so I'll be emailing and making calls then

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

:tpd:
he speaketh from experiencth.
sounds like you just had that problem (still waiting for my re-done pipe as well).

i have to agree, i'd stick with a basic shape, one that you know the pipe maker chosen makes frequently and you like the outcome.

anyone looked at Joel Shapiro and his "chubby" pipes? he was a member of CS a while back.

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

ok, I have emailed and received an initial repsonse from the Boswells.

J.M seems willing to take on our project. I can attest to how well his pipes smoke, and I guarantee he will have the best price point of anyone we've been discussing.

So, take a look here http://www.boswellpipes.com/classicpipegallery.html and post up what catches your eye.

These will be the easiest to have made, and be the most inexpensive. Most of these ran in the 50-90 dollar range when first posted.

I have posted the ones I like, but post yours, or if you see something from a different gallery post that as well. I can call him monday or tuesday if we have a good idea of what we want. I know many wanted a poker, but a nice quarter bent apple or something along those lines may be the best for getting this done and at an agreeable price :wo

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

I'm good with anything from Boswell. I'm glad they're willing to take on the project. I've been wanting to own one for quite some time. Here are a couple that really stand out to me, but like I said I'm cool with what the masses want.

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v1.../free158no.jpg

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v1...KERPIPES49.jpg

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

I like the FINISH on this one :tu but am happy with whatever.

Half-bent apple sounds wonderful for a first time. http://www.boswellpipes.com/images/p...ics%20(25).jpg

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

I like this one.

http://www.boswellpipes.com/images/p...ics%20(51).jpg

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

Can I just say 'Yes!'? I've liked all of the pipes you guys have picked...I am just starting so I'm really open for anything.

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

well, I'll leave this open for another couple days, but I may just tell Senor Boswell, "make your version of a somewhat bent appleish shape, about half smooth and have rusticated

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

I really like this one! It's real nice! I always wanted a Boswell to and that is what I would buy.

But Whatever the pipe may be I'm still in!

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

Would still prefer a poker, but anything goes with me.

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

would love a sitter. especially for herfs :)

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

A sitter would be really nice. I have been wanting to get one and also have been really looking at the Boswell pipes as well.

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

All right. I'm glad this got off the ground. Also really happy that Boswell's said they'd do it.

I'm really up for any shape from Boswell. I'm not picky. Bent Apple, Bulldog, Egg, Dublin, Pot, you get the idea. I'm up for whatever.

Thanks for taking the initiative to organize this and get it off the ground Tim.

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

I like the shapes you guys are picking out. Might I add though, that I am not a big fan of 1/2 smooth 1/2 rusticated.

Is it possible for him to make some and then rusticate the ones that want it?

It would be nice to offer the option if it is doable for him.

Either way though, I am happy. I love Boswell pipes and it is nice to keep it in a decent price range.

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

I agree with him, I would prefer a smooth bowl over a rusticated on, and would greatly appreciate being able to choose if it is an option - make the pipe a bit more personal and all that :)

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

Count me in..I like this one from the link provided by RX2010.

http://www.boswellpipes.com/images/p...ics%20(37).jpg

I wonder if it could be done in a smooth finish??

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

Bravo for Boswell stepping up! We're guaranteed a quality smoker with him at the wheel.

That poker is catching my eye as well. I could use another sitter!

WWhermit
:pi:

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

I just wanted to check in again and say that I am on board. Do these club pipes have a logo on them or other info saying they are for CA?

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

Im sure Boswell's will engrave something on the pipe to accredit it as being a CA club pipe

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

I would imagine so, I'm still in disjointed communication with them, but I'll have some time tomorrow, hopefully I can get J.M. on the phone and get some details figured out

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

I appreciate you heading this up! I can only imagine what a headache it's going to be before it's all said and done. If there's anything I can help with, just shoot me a PM.

I'm definitely on board whatever the pipe and cost ends up being.

Thanks again, Bro!

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

Ya'll could get a stamp made for this pipe and would also be for future CA pipes. Add it to the price, divide the cost amongst all members ordering.

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

I am interested.

I like the looks and style of this.
Tom

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

From the BOSWELL line I like the individuality of these for a club pipe
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v1...Classics46.jpg

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v1...Classics48.jpg

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v1...Classics51.jpg


How about SENATROV or ZEMIN?

Is BOSWELL the final choice?
Tom

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

I'm not a big pipe smoker (yet) but I would definitely be interested:tu

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

Tom, I think we're gonna pursue the Boswell route first, as it will be the most cost effective. If that doesn't work out we can try someone else.

Boswell makes great pipes and it's very likely they'd be under 100 bucks, I just need to get ahold of J.M. who happens to be very busy

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

BOSWELL is not a problem, Tim.

First rate workmanship..
I do like his unique styles the best to exemplify this unique community.
Tom

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

alright guys, I'm calling tomorrow, as requested by Mrs Boswell

hopefully I can get JM on the phone for a few and try to figure something out. I will consider all requests, and I'll try to get 1 or 3 options for us to vote on, and hope then just turn it over to the artisan himself.

There are other great makers out there, but I think Boswell is the best combo of price and quality I've seen, plus his pipes are somewhat quirky, so I think that fits this forum pretty well.

if you have any last minute comments or requests or anything, post em up before tomorrow evening

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

I am very very stoked man. I have been talking with them through emails for a couple weeks as well for a personal pipe. I can not wait to see the one for CA.

Re: Asylum edition/club pipe interest thread
 

Good stuff Tim, I'm excited to see what they come up with.