Re: Looking for a good large (and sturdy) ashtray
 

This is the first time I've heard of problems with the Stinky. I can see where if it takes some hard knocks then a stirrup might get bent or broken, but mine is OK after 18 months. But, I can't say it has been subjected to hard use.

Re: Looking for a good large (and sturdy) ashtray
 

I've had my Stinky for over two years now with no problems and it's been dropped several times.

CAO Cubist is a pain to clean and the letters do pop off.

Re: Looking for a good large (and sturdy) ashtray
 

Didn't even think to mention the pain about cleaning. Very much agree though.

Re: Looking for a good large (and sturdy) ashtray
 

A steel trashcan

Re: Looking for a good large (and sturdy) ashtray
 

OK, as an Officer and a Gentleman - you require both sturdy and something the is fitting to your status. I love my black ashtray:


http://www.cigarasylum.com/vb/showpo...39&postcount=8

http://www.cigarextras.com/index.asp...OD&ProdID=2156

Re: Looking for a good large (and sturdy) ashtray
 

I'm not sure why you'd call me a gentleman.......

Re: Looking for a good large (and sturdy) ashtray
 

First time for me too hearing about issues with stirrups falling off. I've had my stinky with the stand for 3+ years and it's been bounced around with no problems. I Love it and will use nothing other than a stinky.


:tu


Chris.....

Re: Looking for a good large (and sturdy) ashtray
 

Vote for stinky. I have have had 2 now for quite a while. Nothing wrong with either. I even pick it up by the stirrup and take it to the weekly herf at a local bar. I think the GB is still going on. Just click the link and get one for relatively cheap.

Re: Looking for a good large (and sturdy) ashtray
 

That's the game plan. Gonna pull the trigger on that one I do believe.

Re: Looking for a good large (and sturdy) ashtray
 

I had the same concerns with the Stinky . I bought one and now recommend it . However , they are not near as heavy as they appear .