If I like an 8-5-8 I will love....

[Flynnster]

Alright everyone, inviting the guys over for a cigar and poker night, and looking to maybe try something different. I love 858's, how smooth they are, and the creamyness. Also love that they seem to always produce lots of thick smoke for me.


What other sticks should I look at? Trying to keep it within the same general price range.

[icehog3]

More 8-5-8s?

[Flynnster]

More 8-5-8s?

I know that but for some reason I feel like I need to try other cigars!

[icehog3]

I have had some NCs that I would describe as creamy, unfortunately none of the ones I remember come anywhere near the price point of the 8-5-8s. :(

[emopunker2004]

are we talking AF 8-5-8?

[bobarian]

Maybe something in the Hemingway or Don Carlos line? :sh

[emopunker2004]

8-5-8 maduro are good

[DaBear]

I can't remember how much 858s usually go for, but for a lower end guesstimate try any of the Siglos if you can find them, higher end try the EP Carrillo Core Line

[T.G]

Maybe something in the Hemingway or Don Carlos line? :sh

That would be my guess too, since they use the same type of wrapper and similar filler but, like shruggie implies, liking one doesn't necessarily mean you'll like the other.

[chatboardhero]

The Hemingway line is fantastic. My favorite AF for sure. But if you are looking to branch out, there are a myriad of creamy, mild/medium smokes you could try. I enjoy the Leon Jimenez, Perdomo Gran Cru Connecticut, Oliva Connecticut, Nestor Miranda Special Selection, Cruzado, or maybe a Hoyo Excal. If you want to really try something different, but worth a shot, the Tabak Especial from Drew Estate is an interesting departure from traditional smokes. It's coffee infused. I am far from a flavored cigar fan, but I enjoy these from time to time.

[Skywalker]

Brickhouse (made by JC Newman) is in the price range and yummy!:2

[Flynnster]

Alright, I'll give a short story a try (part of the hemingway line, no?) and Skywalker, I do love me a good brickhouse.

[kickerb]

Brickhouse (made by JC Newman) is in the price range and yummy!:2:tpd:

[Skywalker]

Alright, I'll give a short story a try (part of the hemingway line, no?) and Skywalker, I do love me a good brickhouse.

:tu

[Ogre]

EP Corillo, another great stick for the price

[heavyd]

Do you like the 858 Black label or Green label? I have never tried Green. If Black, then you may wanna try Cruzado. Medium body and smooth and creamy.

[SmokinCozy]

Do you like the 858 Black label or Green label? I have never tried Green. If Black, then you may wanna try Cruzado. Medium body and smooth and creamy.

:tpd: I was thinking Cruzado, Illusione, regular line Ashton and La Aroma de Cuba. I found the people that don't smoke all the time like the Ashton's and La Aroma.

[whodeeni]

the new Java mint is VERRRY Creamy, and the mint is extremely light...
you should try it!

[shilala]

I'll say Hemingways, as well. A Signature or Classic. A work of art would be stretching it a bit.

[fritz43096]

I just picked up a 10 pack of Alec Bradley Family Blend. I've only smoked one but it reminded me a lot of my 858s. The La aroma de cuba magnifico was close too.

[Cyrann]

In terms of the Flor Fina 858 from AF, I would have to say that the Hemingway would be the closest in terms of likeness, but if your willing to switch countries of origin and/or brands then I would give the Oliva Serie G Natural (for it has a similar price point and wrapper - the maduro G is CBL so skip that one) a shot.

If you are looking for something that I think you will highly recommend and you are willing to spend a few extra bucks, the Cameroon Cabinet #2 Natural from La Flor Dominicana seems right up your alley being cammy wrapped and from the DR.

Hope that helps.