Just One Cigar

[rhmalone]

If you could only smoke one cigar for the rest of your life, what would you choose and why?

I think for me, I'd have to say the 601 Black, I love everything about this cigar and could smoke it morning, noon or night.

[Tripp]

T110.

'nuff said, IMHO.

[htown]

Cohiba Esplendido with five or more years in the humi.

[mariogolbee]

Cohiba Siglo II.

[jerseystepup]

Cohiba Siglo II.

:tpd: Thought about this as soon as i read the topic..

[maverickdrinker]

cohiba siglo VIs; beautiful cigar.

[JJG]

I'm glad someone else thinks the 601 black labels are as tasty as I do!

but as far as picking one cigar for all time?

jeez... I really can't think of one. I mean, I love a good steak, but it would get old pretty quick if that's the only thing I had to eat for every meal. :(

[icehog3]

jeez... I really can't think of one. I mean, I love a good steak, but it would get old pretty quick if that's the only thing I had to eat for every meal. :(

I typed something similar earlier but didn't hit "submit". I don't know if I would smoke a fraction of what I smoke now if this were the case.

[kgraybill]

I would choose the Gurkha black dragon because it would make me quit smokin.

[markem]

Davidoff Château Latour or Château Mouton Rothschild

if you gotta be limited, be limited in a big way :tu

[danreeve]

Illusione HL

Can't stop buying them.

[dubs chops]

swisher sweet!


















































JK:td

[rhmalone]

I know it's a rather silly question in reality. Truth is, what I was smoking last year at this time isn't what I'm smoking now and the same will likely be true this time next year. But a fun question nonetheless. Plus I'm discovering some new cigars this way.

[csbrewfisher]

This changes all the time for me, but right now I'm really liking the AJF Diesel. I could stay with these a long time.

[issues]

Liga Privada No. 9

Probably not a big surprise considering my avatar...

[JJG]

Truth is, what I was smoking last year at this time isn't what I'm smoking now and the same will likely be true this time next year.

This was almost my response. There's no reason to post my current favorite, since my tastes are constantly changing.

I smoked a MC #4 the other night and I couldn't believe they used to be my go-to cigar. Don't get me wrong, it was great. but sooo rich, like a chocolate covered ice cream sunday. good for an occasional treat, but I would get absolutely sick of them within a week if I tried to smoke them daily now.

[kelmac07]

This thread popped up a month or so ago and my answer is still the same...

CAO MX3

[eber]

I have to agree with others in this thread that it doesnt matter how good a certain cigar is, I would get bored with it relatively quickly

[Adriftpanda]

I would choose the Gurkha black dragon because it would make me quit smokin.

:r:r

I would have to say an age Upmann #1

[MedicCook]

Esencia. :tu

[RevSmoke]

Sorry, I don't see the point?

I smoke a variety of cigars, for different occasions/foods/drinks/moods lead to different tastes.

And what I like today, I may not like 5 years from now.

I don't even have only one favorite.

[Tripp]

So are you guys saying that you don't believe in hypothetical questions?

[SkinsFanLarry]

The Original Master Blend!

Because I think it's a damn good cigar!

[Noomis]

Davidoff Château D'Yquem. Not that I've ever had one. But since we're speaking hypothetically here....

Realistically, though, it might have to be a well-aged Partagas 8-9-8.

[mariogolbee]

So are you guys saying that you don't believe in hypothetical questions?
:tpd:

[troutbreath]

Hmmmmm, not sure what I would do here. I guess I might go with a cigar that I KNOW I like every time, like a AF Hemingway Classic. Or, maybe a WOAM. Or a Tatuaje Unicos.

Or, perhaps I would go with a stick that, when in a new humidor at a B&M, I reach for because I enjoy them so much, like a VSG. Or, maybe that stick that I reach for because I can't get it just everywhere, like a Davidoff Millineum Blend . . .

Can't do it. Can't choose just one.

[longknocker]

cohiba siglo VIs; beautiful cigar.

:tu My Choice!:banger

[Zanaspus]

Any Padron.

[sofaman]

Padron 26 #9 :tu

[massphatness]

Davidoff 3000 because it's the best cigar I've had to date. I curse landhoney (Seth) on a regular basis for gifting it to me. :D

[Subvet642]

Sorry, I don't see the point?

I smoke a variety of cigars, for different occasions/foods/drinks/moods lead to different tastes.

And what I like today, I may not like 5 years from now.

I don't even have only one favorite.

:tpd: But, the one cigar that has never failed to please, no matter what, is Don Diego; they're creamy, smooth and as I'm also a cigarette smoker, I can inhale them, which opens up a whole range of pallet notes. I'm dying to try their Privada No.2 maddies! I assume that I can smoke different vitloas? :ss

[darkninja67]

No contest: PAM Exclusivo

[CigarNut]

My favorite changes all the time; right now I am liking the AF Hemingways and Padrons. If I had to pick one it would be the Padron Family Reserve 45th Maduro.

[CasaDooley]

1492, Habanos 1994 or Partagas 150 Nro.109.
Go big or go home.:ss

[DrDubzz]

Boli PC for me

[poker]

Habanos 1994

[Doctorossi]

Punch DC

[Tripnastic]

AF Hemingway Signature. If it's the only one ever again, I've got to go with the one I've found to be most consistent.

[icehog3]

Habanos 1994

Playing along with the hypothetical, this would be my choice as well.

[RazzBarlow]

In this perfect hypothetical world, I would have to choose Padron Anniversary 1964 Maduro Torpedo. It's a nice smooth smoke with a lot of flavor for me.

But, I've recently been introduced to CC's for the first time in my life (Thanks S.H.I.T. heads). They're a different animal entirely! So, if you were to ask me this question again in a month or two, I might have a different answer.

[M1903A1]

Party Shorts, with about a year and a half/two years' age. (I.e. out of the sick period and back to normal).

Not only do I not get tired of them, when I finish one I have to fight myself not to start up another! :D

[cigarlvr]

Padron 44th

[Chemyst]

I'd go with AF Hemi Signature maduro.
Very consistent and tasty cigar.

A close second is PAM and,
third either Ashton VSG or San Cristobal.

subject to change, of course.

Chemyst :cool2:

[Doctorossi]

San Cristobal

Made my short-list, too. :tu

[Neuromancer]

BBF...but I'd have to have enough of them that they could be aged in rotation so I'm never without one that doesn't have a least a year or more on it...

[duckmanco]

said the same thing a million times before, and it ain't sexy or expensive or impossible to find:

Rocky Patel Sungrown PC - usually smokes these in the factory select bundles, and to me, its what I think of when I want a flat out F*cking CIGAR...this blend tastes like what a cigar should taste like IMO, and the construction/draw has been perfect on every one.

[LockOut]

LCG #4 or maybe a Boli CE

[cherrybomb]

psd4 when it is on

[rhmalone]

Some great cigars being proclaimed here (and some that are new to me).

[irklak]

Partagas Series D #4

Perfect flavor and size

[Mugen910]

So many great cigars out there..how do you choose just one?

Also..who actually thinks that cigars won't change a bit as time passes?

but if I were to play along I'd like a Festival 2000

[Doctorossi]

Also..who actually thinks that cigars won't change a bit as time passes?

Did someone say they wouldn't? Just one more factor to weigh into your choice.