Top 5 Sticks of All Time

[kelmac07]

Although I have only been seriously torching stogies for a short time, I decided to compile my Top Five Favorite Sticks. Those that know me are well aware of my fondness for maduros and what a maddie whore I have become over the past 5-6 months (:D thanks JK...high five). Here are my favorites in no particular order:

http://i672.photobucket.com/albums/vv82/kelmac07_photo/IMG_1188.jpg

Alec Bradley Tempus Imperator
CAO MX3
Camacho Triple Maduro
Davidoff Maduro
Arturo Fuente Cuban Corona Maduro

Been on the lookout for the new Alec Bradley Tempus Magistri Maduro, which might bump one of these off the list (was supposed to be released 01 Nov 09), no luck yet). :tu



What are your Top Five Favorites??

[Emjaysmash]

The triple maduro is the sheeeet!

[Kreth]

I don't know if I could narrow it down to 5. I've been introduced to a lot of tasty sticks through bombs and trades. Let's see:
Kristoff maddie
Bucanero Full Sail
DPG Series JJ maddie
MoW Ruination
Sancho Panza Double Maduro

But then there's DPG Black or Blue label, Illusione cg:4, Tempus, Perdomo Oscuro, Gurkha Doble Maduro, RP Vintage 90, RP OWR, Padron 64, Padilla 32, XX handrolls from Habana Reserve in Albany, NY; ITSF, Taboo Twist, Goviado... You get the idea. :r
Posted via Mobile Device

[kelmac07]

Oh trust me Jeff...if I wanted to expand...

DPG JJ Series Maduro
Perdomo Lot #23 Maduro
Sancho Panza Double Quixote Maduro
Kristoff Maduro
Padron 2000 Maduro
Arturo Fuente Hemmingway Maduro
J Fuego 777
Xikar HC Havana Colorado
Tampa Sweethearts #500 Maduro

Notice the pattern?? :r:r:r I could keep going and going..that is why I nailed it down to five.

[captain53]

Lots of good ones on your list, that Camacho is definitely on mine. I would have to do a lot of thinking for all 5 but no doubt the LGC Serie R 6 & 7 are both on there up top.:banger

[poriggity]

Top 5.. Hmm.. Thats a hard one.. As of right now, if we are talking only NC...
Tatuaje Boris
Cuba Aliados Miami
Illusione MJ12
CAO La Traviata
Padilla Miami
Those are in order of preference...

Scott

[GTsetGO]

damn i still need to get my hands on some of those MX3's.

[Chemyst]

Only 5?

Let's see...

PAM
AF Hemingway maduro, any
San Cristobal by Ashton
Ashton VSG
RP Olde World Reserve, either wrapper

Except for the PAMs, I get to smoke these fairly regularly.
Lucky me.

Chemyst :cool2:

[marge796]

Love the AB Tempus!


:tu


Chris.....

[GTsetGO]

but mine right now are:

Ashton VSG
RP Edge Sumatra
Oliva V
Cain Habano
Arturo Fuente Cuban Corona Maduro

[longknocker]

Didn't Like The AB Harvest Edition, May Need To Sample The Tempus!:tu
Mine Would Be:
1. Fuente OpusX
2. Padron 1926 Nat
3. Avo Companero Limited '09
4. Gran Habano 3 Siglos
5. Any Illusione

[Kreth]

Gran Habano 3 Siglos
I like these, too. According to the latest CI catalog they're being discontinued due to a trademark issue. :(
Posted via Mobile Device

[longknocker]

I like these, too. According to the latest CI catalog they're being discontinued due to a trademark issue. :(
Posted via Mobile Device

That's What I Heard, too, Jeff!:( Seems All The Good Reasonably Priced Cigars are discontinued.:(

[Kreth]

That's What I Heard, too, Jeff!:( Seems All The Good Reasonably Priced Cigars are discontinued.:(
I'm assuming it's just an issue with the band or name. Hopefully, they'll get rebranded and rereleased.

EDIT: Yep, according to The Stogie Guys (http://www.stogieguys.com/2009/06/06302009-stogie-news-cigar-makers-talk-new-releases.html), it's being rebranded as the Gran Habano SL3 due to a trademark dispute with a new smoke from Altadis.
Posted via Mobile Device

[JJG]

hmm my NC list would include, in no particular order:

AVO XO
Tatuaje brown label
Casa Fuente or Opus X
La Riqueza
Bobalu vintage Dominican

That's just what I've been enjoying lately. My top 5 is constantly changing, as I suspect most people's are.

I've only been smoking seriously for about 6 years but it's dramatic how much my tastes have changed. I started out enjoying sweet, full bodied maduros. My favorite cigar was the ERdM robusto larga maduro. I didn't like Fuente, AVO, or Tatuaje (now my top 3) and most cigars I purchased were at least 50+ ring gauge.

The most dramatic revelation for me was buying a box of CCs for the first time. My expectations were high, but that first box of Boli PCs exceeded them 10 times over. I went through a period where I only smoked Cubans and nothing else even came close.

I still prefer the flavor profile I get from most full bodied Cubans, but for the past few years I've been buying a lot of NC singles too. My intent was to try and find cigars that came close to the flavors I like so much in CCs.

What I found was very surprising. The NCs that appeal to me now are the exact opposite of what I started out enjoying. I've decided that mild is not a bad thing. Hell, compared to many of the popular NC brands out there, I think Cubans are very mild. Connecticut wrappers taste good to me now. Fuente and AVO are some of my favorite cigars, and I used to think they were overpriced and bland. In fact, there are more Dominicans on my top 5 than Nicaraguans. Occasionally I'll pick up a robusto, but I rarely smoke anything over 46 RG.

I have no idea what my preferences will be 6 months from now, or 2 years down the road, but always having something fresh and new to smoke is part of the fun of this hobby.

cheers! :ss

[JohnnyKay5]

High Five Mac.. I will claim responsibility for pushing you down the slope. I will not claim the AB though. That goes to ferg. I think I'm the only guy on this site who is not a fan.

[Adriftpanda]

High Five Mac.. I will claim responsibility for pushing you down the slope. I will not claim the AB though. That goes to ferg. I think I'm the only guy on this site who is not a fan.

Chest bump Johnny, I thought I was the only one did not like the AB! Now I know there are others haha

[poriggity]

I'm assuming it's just an issue with the band or name. Hopefully, they'll get rebranded and rereleased.

EDIT: Yep, according to The Stogie Guys (http://www.stogieguys.com/2009/06/06302009-stogie-news-cigar-makers-talk-new-releases.html), it's being rebranded as the Gran Habano SL3 due to a trademark dispute with a new smoke from Altadis.
Posted via Mobile Device

Great.. ANOTHER trademark dispute with Altadis. Fantastic.

[Kreth]

Great.. ANOTHER trademark dispute with Altadis. Fantastic.
Yeah, I was wondering how a new smoke trumps an existing brand, but I'm glad they'll still be making them. Plus, CI has great pricing on the 3 Siglos due to the "closeout."
Posted via Mobile Device

[JohnnyKay5]

Chest bump Johnny, I thought I was the only one did not like the AB! Now I know there are others haha

a manly chest bump at that!

[GHC_Hambone]

Although I have only been seriously torching stogies for a short time, I decided to compile my Top Five Favorite Sticks. Those that know me are well aware of my fondness for maduros and what a maddie whore I have become over the past 5-6 months (:D thanks JK...high five). Here are my favorites in no particular order:

http://i672.photobucket.com/albums/vv82/kelmac07_photo/IMG_1188.jpg

Alec Bradley Tempus Imperator
CAO MX3
Camacho Triple Maduro
Davidoff Maduro
Arturo Fuente Cuban Corona Maduro

Been on the lookout for the new Alec Bradley Tempus Magistri Maduro, which might bump one of these off the list (was supposed to be released 01 Nov 09), no luck yet). :tu



What are your Top Five Favorites??

Davidoff Maduro?! I didnt even know they made those!

[kelmac07]

Davidoff Maduro?! I didnt even know they made those!

They are damn tasty...but at $ 17.00 a stick, I don't get to enjoy them that often.

[Dunkel]

Top 5 would be tough but...

Perdomo Reserve Oscuro
Patel Brothers
DPG JJ Maduro
Perdomo 10th Anniversary Maduro
San Cristobal

would be a fine start

[Starscream]

NC only? :hm

PAM 64 Principe
El Rico Habano
JdN Antano Consul
Perdomo Reserve Sungrown
Fuente Hemingway Short Story

[alfbacca]

Wow, of all time? Ok, here goes (in no particular order):

Tatuaje Havana Cazadores
El Triunfador Lancero
Opus XXX Power Ranger
Tatuaje Verocu East Coast
DPG Cuban Classic Perla

I like my Nicaraguan tobacco.

[Lucky_Hippo]

Tough call. Everytime I read someone else's picks I have to go back and re-think my own.:D But for 11/09/09 this early in the am I'll go with this line up.

Ashton VSG
PAM
Oliva serie V Maduro
DPG serie JJ
E.O. Cubao

[coastietech]

Haha... this one is actually pretty easy for me. If I could have an unlimited supply of only these 5 smokes I would be happy.

Illusione cg:4
Tat Havana IV Hermosa
Padron Palmas
Anejo #49
Hemi Maduro

[Volt]

Well, I have noticed either my taste are settling in or the ones I like really appeal to me. The price range and "quality" seem to jump around a lot as well. As with the others in no particular order:

1. Oliva O Bolds
2. 2003 Dunhills (thanks Simon)
3. H. Uppman Vintage Cameroons
4. AF Chateau Fuente (King B prefered, but all are tasty)
5. PAM

[elderboy02]

Man, this is really hard

Tatuaje Black
Padron 1926 No. 9 Maduro
Don Pepin Garcia Serie JJ Maduro
Don Pepin Garcia Cuban Classic 1977 corona (petit lancero size)
Partagas Corona Senior Tubo

[Addiction]

Hmmm, of all time? That requires some thought but I think its:

1994
Dunhill Estupendo
Dunhill Cabinetta
Cohiba Milli Piramide
Cohiba Double Corona EL

I don't know if thats the order I would put them in, but those are them.

[Uflbassin]

Well there are a few sticks I can't picture myself ever getting tired of:

El Triunfador
Casa Fernandez
Cruzado
DPG Blue
Tatuaje - everything

I'd have to say, if Pete Johnson and Don Pepin have anything to do with the sticks, they're up there on the list. :ss

[bobarian]

Nice group, but I will be willing to bet that in 6 months maybe two of those will be on your next list. Tastes change. :2

[TheTraveler]

My top 5:
---------
1. Bolivar Royal Corona (CC)
2. A Fuente Hemingway (NC)
3. Punch Cafe Royal (NC)
4. Punch Punch (NC)
5. Sancho Panza Double Maduro (NC)

[jledou]

Until I find some new ones

Oliva MB III
CAO Italia
HdM Dark Night
DPG cuban classic
Opus X

[ThinkB4Umove]

My Top 5 are as follow;

1. El Triunfador
2. Illusione Epernay La Elegance
3. Cabaiguan Corona Extra
4. 601 Green Banded El Punto
5. Tatuaje Series P P1

[covetry]

illusione cg:4
Padron 80th Perfecto
Arturo Fuente Hemingway Signature Maduro
Padron 1964 Princepe
Padron 1926 No. 9

[McSmokey]

AF Anejo
Cain Maduro
DPG Blue
My Father Le Bijou
Ashton VSG

[Brooks W]

Hmm...of all time? Let's see:

Cohiba Gran Reserva
Tat SW Maduro
'99 WOAM
Partagás Serie D No. 4 Reserva
Tat OR Noella

~brooks