Best stick you've ever had

[RightAJ]

What is it (or what are they if there's more than one)?

I really don't know what mine would be... Possibly the Drac, Padron 26 #35, or a Monti #2 :hm

aj

[acarr]

Oliva Master Blends II Robusto followed by Litto Gomez Diez Small Batch #2 These were far and above anything else I have tried.

[massphatness]

A Cohiba Selecion Reserva Coronas Especiales gifted to me by Poker.

A close second though would be an 03 Party Lons courtesy of Moglman.

Both were mind-blowingly outstanding smokes.

[KidRock]

1999 Romeo Churchill.....

[DougBushBC]

1995 OR Opus X Belicoso (from TanithT)... Absolutely the most refined and delicate smoke I have ever had.

[shilala]

There's too many to list, but the first best stick I ever had was a Padron 1926 #6 Maduro.
The last best stick I ever had was a Litto Gomez Diez 06 Oscuro Oriental.

[Scottw]

Monte Edmundo from 06 I think it was.

[leasingthisspace]

Mine was a Padron 2xxx or 3xxx maddie that had some age on it. The cello was the only clue of how old it was. It was a gift from JK. I am still trying to smoke one that good.
Posted via Mobile Device

[boonedoggle]

Consistently Padron 64 Maddies, all vitolas. Pete Johnson's stuff is close, but those PAMs just do something for me! :)

[Kreth]

Kristoff maddies. Great flavor, and excellent presentation.
Posted via Mobile Device

[14holestogie]

00 RyJ Churchill is the best I've had to this point (:tu Vin), but I'm still searching. :)

[Emjaysmash]

PSD4 or the LCG MdO #2

[CasaDooley]

Best stick so far would be a tie between a 98 PLPC and a 96 Cohiba Siglo I. Both had flavors that were off the chart!:dr

[kelmac07]

CAO MX3 :tu

[SilverFox]

Cohiba Esplendido 2002 Seleccion Reserva

No close seconds............yet

[sikk50]

LGC #3 given to me and shared with Skywalker on his birthday!

[e-man67]

I use to think it was the Tat Black but now I think it is the Boris....

[bigheadmark]

Best stick so far would be a tie between a 98 PLPC and a 96 Cohiba Siglo I. Both had flavors that were off the chart!:dr

what's a PLPC

[bigheadmark]

My most memorable and best smokes was one I smoked in our rental car on the way back from Cigar Aficianado's Big smoke in Chicago in May of 2000...
It was a Perdomo La tradicion torpedo which had probably one of the oiliest wrappers, richest flavor and smoke I have ever smoked..
the current La Tradicion's are nothing like the ones we smoked back then....

[Steelerfanatic]

what's a PLPC

Por Larranaga Petite Corona

[coastietech]

Right now I would have to say the two that stand out in my mind as the best I've had were my very first Boli PC and my very first Anejo #49

[yourchoice]

I won't swear it was the best ever, but the Cohiba Siglo VI tubo I had while at the Phillies World Series Championship parade down Broad Street was mighty fine and quite memorable last Halloween.

[longknocker]

Hands Down, Boli GM!:)

[Blueface]

Hands down, 1970's Monte #2 Dunhill Selection.

[RightAJ]

Hands down, 1970's Monte #2 Dunhill Selection.

:dr Thats somethin that pops up in my dreams :p

aj

[pfm721]

Too many to list but the most recent stick has to be a Litto Gomez Small Batch #2. That cigar was so good it was shocking. I just remember thinking all along how I couldn't believe I'd never heard of it till a buddy gifted it to me.

[Poronico]

Oliva Master Blends II Robusto followed by Litto Gomez Diez Small Batch #2 These were far and above anything else I have tried.

This is kind of shocking to me, EVERYONE I have spoken with about these sticks say the 2's are horrible compared to the 1 and the 3. Glad you enjoy them :)

[kgoings]

01 Upmann #2 or LCG MdO #1

[acarr]

This is kind of shocking to me, EVERYONE I have spoken with about these sticks say the 2's are horrible compared to the 1 and the 3. Glad you enjoy them :)

I never got to try them fresh. So my experience is only with them aged for quite some time and they rock!

[Poronico]

RASCC would be my morning cigar, Lunch Cigar LGC MdO #3, Dinner Trinidad Fundadores, and for the hell of it a Tatuaje T110

[Poronico]

I never got to try them fresh. So my experience is only with them aged for quite some time and they rock!

I will keep that in mind, My B & M has a bunch of these in stock. I will try one tonight.

[acarr]

I will keep that in mind, My B & M has a bunch of these in stock. I will try one tonight.

Let me know your opinion on it!:banger

[Darrell]

80's Davidoff 5000 (Cuban)

[kelmac07]

80's Davidoff 5000 (Cuban)

Sitting on one of these...tempts me every day!! :dr

[TideRoll]

Tough one. I've had a number of very memorable stogies. I had several Party Ds from the same batch that really blew me away. I had an 80s vintage R&J Churchill that was simply outstanding, having had enough time to really get some character. I had several Montes that were a decade or two old that I thought were particularly tasty. I'll go with that old R&J.

[poriggity]

I use to think it was the Tat Black but now I think it is the Boris....

Agreed, to date in my smoking career, the boris is hands down my favorite cigar.
Scott

[Starscream]

1950s Blackstone

[s0leful0ne]

00 RyJ Churchill is the best I've had to this point (:tu Vin), but I'm still searching. :)

Off the top of my head thats the one that comes to mind :) I need to find more ;)

[RevSmoke]

1980 Montecristo #2.

[ChicagoWhiteSox]

H Upmann No.2 from 1990, simply amazing. I was sitting on the lake in northern Wisconsin this past summer when I smoked this. Great experience overall:tu

[kgraybill]

I have to say the Padron # 35 maduro

[VirtualSmitty]

Mantequilla toro.

[RevSmoke]

H Upmann No.2 from 1990, simply amazing. I was sitting on the lake in northern Wisconsin this past summer when I smoked this. Great experience overall:tu

Any cigar I smoke sitting on a lake in Northern Wisconsin becomes a great experience - overall.

[Mr.Maduro]

Hands down, 1970's Monte #2 Dunhill Selection.

Luck of the f'ng draw...(pun intended) mine was hopelessly plugged!

I think I might have 1 more....;)

I'm still thinking of my best stick....i will post in a few days....really need to think about it.

[RightAJ]

Luck of the f'ng draw...(pun intended) mine was hopelessly plugged!

I think I might have 1 more....;)

I'm still thinking of my best stick....i will post in a few days....really need to think about it.

You've had a 70s Dunhill and you still have to think about it? I hate you :D

aj

[BillyCigars]

Mantequilla toro.

:r

A 1984 Dunhill Estupendo. Gifted to me by none other than the VirtualSmitty himself! :tu:tu

[Lucky_Hippo]

Ashton VSG Belicoso #1

I've had many fine cigars over the years, but when I come across these they always hit the spot.

[cbsmokin]

I've had several favorites:

1. 2001 Monte Tubo (The first CC that made me get it)
2. 1990's RYJ Churchill Tubo. (The first CC that made me understand why we age them)
3. 80's Davidoff 5000 (First of the high end CC smokes)

[elderboy02]

Tatuaje Black
Padron Serie 1926 No. 9 Maduro

[DBall]

Sitting on one of these...tempts me every day!! :dr

Yours is a 3000, not a 5000. ;)


Best I've had in a pass would be a XXXIV Feria Internacional De Barcelona Cubatabaco 1966, followed closely by a Davidoff Y'Quem (which was definitely not expired :r)

Best I've had solo would be a pretty tight tie between a Davidoff 3000 and a 70's LGC MdO #4