Looking for a good large (and sturdy) ashtray

[icantbejon]

Any recommendations?

[marge796]

Can't go wrong with Stinky.


:2


Chris.....

[captain53]

CAO Cubist is pretty popular, I have one works good also not too expensive. 55 gallon drum works better though and is sturdy and ;s

[replicant_argent]

Can't go wrong with Stinky.


:2


Chris.....

From hearing about many of the Stinkys stirrups falling off after being knocked around, I don't know that your statement would be entirely correct. I imagine some of the guys who have had to weld/epoxy/solder theirs together might chime in here.

[SmokeyJoe]

Can't go wrong with Stinky.


:2


Chris.....

Love mine! Some people have a little trouble with the stirrups popping off... but mine is just fine after 18 months or so on the back porch. :tu

http://i211.photobucket.com/albums/bb28/Revtiger/Cigars/stinky-ashtray.jpg

[kelmac07]

I love my Stinky too!!

[icantbejon]

I was looking at a Stinky in the local B&M and really liked it. Perhaps this is a sign.

[Starz26]

CAO Cubist is pretty popular, I have one works good also not too expensive. 55 gallon drum works better though and is sturdy and ;s

Where can you get one that is under $100.00???? I wish I could find it somewhere...

[Darrell]

The stinky is a great ashtray and I totally see where Pete is coming from about the stirrups. In Stinky's defense though, 9/10 people seem to store their ashtray on a table and the stirrup is just a small piece of metal. Any significant fall will cause one to bust off. It's a pain in the ass, but it's not such a pain that I would say it's not a good choice. It's good sized, well made, cleans easy. I love my stinkies (herf and personal).

[yourchoice]

I have a Stinky and one of my stirrups have fallen off. It didn't drop or anything drastic. I picked it up gripping it between my thumb and forefinger and "pop". With that being said, I do still like the ashtray. Just need to get around to making the repair.

[icantbejon]

Where can you get one that is under $100.00???? I wish I could find it somewhere...

I got my cubist for around $50 I do believe. I didn't find that to fit the "sturdy" category. All the letters popped off. Very annoying.

[captain53]

Where can you get one that is under $100.00???? I wish I could find it somewhere...

I bought mine a a local B&M a couple of years ago for $45 on sale but here is one for $49.95, never bought from this supplier so might want to check out first.

http://www.cheapercigars.com/ashtrays-by-brand.html

[captain53]

Where can you get one that is under $100.00???? I wish I could find it somewhere...

Here it is even cheaper, again I have no experience with this dealer either:

http://www.cigarplace.biz/index.cfm/a/catalog.prodshow/vid/36762

[ucla695]

Another vote for the Stinky!! I've had mine for years and love it! :tu

[hotreds]

Another vote for the Stinky. Indeed, it may not be as sturdy as the 55 gallon drum, but it looks a lot better! If you want tank-like, use the drum, otherwise Stinky is way to go!

[poriggity]

Im all about the stinky ashtray. I have had mine for at least 3 years I think... maybe 2.5.. Works flawlessly.
Scott

[bookman]

I use a coffee can. I've dented the rim so my sticks sit perfectly.

[Waynegro1]

Another vote for Stinky!! As far as the stirrups falling off, I've never had a problem and I've had mine for almost two years. I also read, Stinky addressed the stirrup problem. So, should be a safe bet. :tu

[Poronico]

Casa Fuente has some beautiful and reasonably priced ash trays usually around 50 bucks for their large one

[dunng]

PM sent with Stinky GB Info... :D

[Titan410]

This is the first time I've heard of problems with the Stinky. I can see where if it takes some hard knocks then a stirrup might get bent or broken, but mine is OK after 18 months. But, I can't say it has been subjected to hard use.

[Shadow]

I've had my Stinky for over two years now with no problems and it's been dropped several times.

CAO Cubist is a pain to clean and the letters do pop off.

[icantbejon]

CAO Cubist is a pain to clean and the letters do pop off.

Didn't even think to mention the pain about cleaning. Very much agree though.

[Sr Mike]

Any recommendations?

A steel trashcan

[Volt]

OK, as an Officer and a Gentleman - you require both sturdy and something the is fitting to your status. I love my black ashtray:


http://www.cigarasylum.com/vb/showpost.php?p=476939&postcount=8

http://www.cigarextras.com/index.asp?PageAction=VIEWPROD&ProdID=2156

[icantbejon]

I'm not sure why you'd call me a gentleman.......

[marge796]

This is the first time I've heard of problems with the Stinky. I can see where if it takes some hard knocks then a stirrup might get bent or broken, but mine is OK after 18 months. But, I can't say it has been subjected to hard use.

First time for me too hearing about issues with stirrups falling off. I've had my stinky with the stand for 3+ years and it's been bounced around with no problems. I Love it and will use nothing other than a stinky.


:tu


Chris.....

[DPD6030]

Vote for stinky. I have have had 2 now for quite a while. Nothing wrong with either. I even pick it up by the stirrup and take it to the weekly herf at a local bar. I think the GB is still going on. Just click the link and get one for relatively cheap.

[icantbejon]

Vote for stinky. I have have had 2 now for quite a while. Nothing wrong with either. I even pick it up by the stirrup and take it to the weekly herf at a local bar. I think the GB is still going on. Just click the link and get one for relatively cheap.

That's the game plan. Gonna pull the trigger on that one I do believe.

[Bubba - NJ]

I had the same concerns with the Stinky . I bought one and now recommend it . However , they are not near as heavy as they appear .