Cigar everyone has had?

[darkninja67]

Just wondering which cigar do you think everyone has had here at the madhouse?

I am thinking the AF Short Story as they are extremely popular. Second guess would be a Padron X000.

[adampc22]

a rocky patel 1990


sorry to put a stick in the works but i have never had a af short story or a padron x000

[darkninja67]

a rocky patel 1990


sorry to put a stick in the works but i have never had a af short story or a padron x000

I would put them on my short list if I were you. Good call on the RP, I have had a few.

[adampc22]

I would put them on my short list if I were you. Good call on the RP, I have had a few.

i plan to but thay are hard to find in these parts lol

[Kwilkinson]

a rocky patel 1990


sorry to put a stick in the works but i have never had a af short story or a padron x000

+1 on the AF short story. Never had it.

I've only had Padron 3000, but I like it well enough that I don't need to try any of the others in the series. :ss

[acruce]

That was one of my first cigars I tried when I began smoking .

[BlackIrish]

I've had both of those. Other possibilities:
Rocky Patel Vintage 1990 or 1992
Montecristo

[Footbag]

Short Story is what I first thought when I saw the post.

[darkninja67]

Short Story is what I first thought when I saw the post.

a lot off the big retailers are out of stock on them so that is why I thought Short Story.

[Prospector]

Just wondering which cigar do you think everyone has had here at the madhouse?

I am thinking the AF Short Story as they are extremely popular. Second guess would be a Padron X000.

I certainly plan to but haven't quite gotten there yet. I would imagine a lot more of us have had a 5 Vegas Gold or Classic, though.

[mikeyj23]

I certainly plan to but haven't quite gotten there yet. I would imagine a lot more of us have had a 5 Vegas Gold or Classic, though.

I'd guess not - 5 Vegas is only at certain online retailers and not terribly common in B&Ms I've been to.
Posted via Mobile Device

[South Shield]

Padron X000

[RevSmoke]

I wouldn't go to the Hemingway line, though AF might be the line to choose.

AF Chateau

Have had many Padron 2000, 3000 and the odd 4000 & 5000.

What about others - Punch? La Gloria Cubano? Saint Luis Rey?

[nozero]

I've had several different Padrons, only one Short Story.

[acarr]

I would guess some kind of Macanudo since that is what every B&M gives to their new smokers. If they count probably also something like a Swisher Sweet or Backwoods.

[Tredegar]

I have never had a AF Short Story but I have had some of the Padrons. I have, and do have, some RP 1990s. Another possibility is a Punch Rothschild.

[ChicagoWhiteSox]

something from Oliva

[eber]

I would probably say any of the RP Vintage line

[UPHOTO]

Padron X000 without a doubt.

I've had a 2nd of the RP 90 but that's it. Only had 2 short stories but I've had one.

[MTB996]

Fuente 858
Padron 2000
Gurhka anything (usually only once)
Fake Cohiba

[Smokin Gator]

Fake Cohiba

:r:r

Could be the closest though.

[bvilchez]

DPG maybe?
Taboo possibly

RyJ
Montecristo
Padron x000

[robofan]

No such thing.

[Skywalker]

All of the above... except the fake Cohiba or Cohibo!!!:r

[troutbreath]

Never had a Patel 1990. Had a pair of 1992's, though.

How about a Romeo y Julietta red band (I have no idea what that on is called). I see those everywhere, and actually smoked one from a sampler.

While band Ashton?
Davidoff Millineum Blend #1?





I keed.

[Thrak]

Everyone I know, even those that dont smoke but once a year, have had a DonDeigo Playboy...

Other than that, has to be a Macanudo

[boonedoggle]

I was thinking maybe a DR RyJ...either that, or a Cohiba Behike.:)

[lightning9191]

No such thing.

:tpd: I don't think we'll find one unless we do a group buy and force all inmates to participate:ss

[WildBlueSooner]

Swisher Sweet. Everyone has been that drunk at least once!

[ucla695]

Definitely one of the Padron x000 and one of the more common Fuentes.

[Wondering Nomad]

It was mentioned previously and I'll second it - 858. Who hasn't had Carlos's favorite cigar?

[dubnick]

RP Sungrown??

[Mugen910]

I would guess some kind of Macanudo since that is what every B&M gives to their new smokers. If they count probably also something like a Swisher Sweet or Backwoods.

:tpd:

or a Black and Mild.

[BMTA]

Like Thrak said. We may hide it, but we've all had a Macanudo somewhere down the line!

[GhostRyder]

Black & Mild or Swisher Sweet.

A lot of the other ones (see "real cigars") are hit or miss at B&Ms, although I think the Padron X000 series is the most common of the bunch.

RP Vintages are also pretty common from what I've seen.

[smokin5]

Don't forget some of the "standards":
Punch Rothchild
Romeo y Julieta Bully
Arturo Fuente Chateau Fuente

I'm sure many if not most of us had these at some time
in our smoking careers.


Oh, and Garcia y Vega.:ss

[icehog3]

:tpd:

or a Black and Mild.

Smoked a boatload of those 20 years ago. ;)

[darkninja67]

I think my first cigar smoked was a Macanudo Hyde Park back in 1995 or so.

[sodomanaz]

Like Thrak said. We may hide it, but we've all had a Macanudo somewhere down the line!

I've had a few Macs.

[DPD6030]

I also have never smoked a short story but I do enjoy the RP vintages.